Benchmark of computational hydraulics models for open-channel flow with lateral cavities
Open Access
- 2 September 2024
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Journal of Hydraulic Research
- Vol. 62 (5) , 441-460
Abstract
Computational models in hydro-environmental engineering are diverse in their background formulation and span from two-dimensional depth-averaged shallow water models, to complex fully three-dimensional turbulence models resolving large-eddy simulation with surface capturing techniques, and to Lagrangian particle-based methods. This paper presents a first-of-its-kind comparison of six different computational hydraulics fluid dynamics models, namely Iber+, HO-SWM, GBVC, OpenFOAM (RANS), Hydro3D (LES) and DualSPHysics (SPH), in the prediction of mean velocities and free-surface dynamics in two benchmarks involving open-channel flows with symmetric lateral cavities. Results show that shallow-water models capture relatively well the main large-scale coherent structures of the in-cavity flow, with wider shear layers compared to three-dimensional models, and higher velocities in the main channel. Three-dimensional RANS, LES and SPH yield improved predictions of mean velocities compared with experimental data. Computational cost has been quantified for all models with a logarithmic growth when increasing model complexity. The transverse standing wave is captured by most models, with the shallow-water ones matching the theoretical value, while the three-dimensional models overestimate it slightly.Keywords
Funding Information
- European Regional Development Fund
- Dame Kathleen Ollerenshaw Fellowship
- University of Manchester
- Regional Government of Aragón
- ERC-StG 2021 (101039181-SEDAHEAD)
- Ministerio de Universidades (33.50.460A.752)
- European Union NextGenerationEU/PRTR
- University of Vigo
- SciNet HPC Consortium
- Innovation, Science and Economic Development Canada
- Digital Research Alliance of Canada
- Ontario Research Fund: Research Excellence
- University of Toronto
This publication has 67 references indexed in Scilit:
- DualSPHysics: from fluid dynamics to multiphysics problemsComputational Particle Mechanics, 2022
- Quasi-3D two-phase model for dam-break flow over movable bed based on a non-hydrostatic depth-integrated model with a dynamic rough wall lawAdvances in Water Resources, 2019
- Morphological resilience to flow fluctuations of fine sediment deposits in bank lateral cavitiesAdvances in Water Resources, 2018
- Dual integral porosity shallow water model for urban flood modellingAdvances in Water Resources, 2017
- Extension and application of the Preissmann slot model to 2D transient mixed flowsAdvances in Water Resources, 2015
- Numerical calculation for bed variation in compound-meandering channel using depth integrated model without assumption of shallow water flowAdvances in Water Resources, 2014
- LE of shallow mixing interfaces: A reviewEnvironmental Fluid Mechanics, 2013
- Experimental and computational investigation of local scour around bridge piersAdvances in Water Resources, 2012
- Depth Averaged Modelling of Turbulent Shallow Water Flow with Wet-Dry FrontsArchives of Computational Methods in Engineering, 2007
- Application of the energy-dissipation model of turbulence to the calculation of flow near a spinning discLetters in Heat and Mass Transfer, 1974