Against Nature: How Arguments about the Naturalness of Marriage Privilege Heterosexuality
- 19 March 2012
- journal article
- Published by Wiley in Journal of Social Issues
- Vol. 68 (1) , 46-62
Abstract
This article examines the public debate over marriage law to investigate how arguments based on claims about what is natural privilege some relationships while stigmatizing others and justifying discriminatory policies toward sexual minorities. Articles about same‐sex marriage appearing in major newspapers were content‐coded according to absence or presence of four dimensions of naturalness: change over time, norms, procreation, and welfare of children. Arguments invoking change over time were most frequent (39%), and procreation appeared least (10%). The use of arguments based on the moral status of marriage was associated with the use of each of the four dimensions based on naturalness. Mentions of race, including comparisons to racial struggles, appeared in 20% of the articles, making them just as common as child welfare. Results are discussed in terms of the power of the concept of naturalness to legitimize and maintain privilege, and the intersectionality of race and sexual orientation.Keywords
This publication has 24 references indexed in Scilit:
- Exploring Levels of Christian Privilege Awareness among Preservice TeachersJournal of Social Issues, 2012
- Same‐Sex Marriage: The Social and Psychological Implications of Policy and DebatesJournal of Social Issues, 2011
- “More natural but less normal”: Reconsidering medicalisation and agency through women’s accounts of menstrual suppressionSocial Science & Medicine, 2010
- The use and abuse of religious beliefs in dividing and conquering between socially marginalized groups: The same-sex marriage debate.American Psychologist, 2009
- The existence bias.Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 2009
- Essentialism and attribution of monstrosity in racist discourse: Right‐wing internet postings about Africans and JewsJournal of Community & Applied Social Psychology, 2009
- Interpersonal Disgust, Ideological Orientations, and Dehumanization as Predictors of Intergroup AttitudesPsychological Science, 2007
- Naturalistic Fallacy Errors in Lay Interpretations of Psychological Science: Data and Reflections on the Rind, Tromovitch, and Bauserman (1998) ControversyBasic and Applied Social Psychology, 2005
- The psychology of doing nothing: Forms of decision avoidance result from reason and emotion.Psychological Bulletin, 2003
- Punks, Bulldaggers, and Welfare Queens: The Radical Potential of Queer Politics?GLQ, 1997