Synthetic Medical Data vs. The Four Principles: Ethical Trade-Offs and Zombie Data
Open Access
- 20 August 2026
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Springer Nature in Health Care Analysis
- p. 1-16
Abstract
Rapid advances in AI for medical applications are accompanied by an increasing demand for vast datasets. Privacy constraints – legal restrictions such as GDPR, as well as more general ethical concerns – pose significant barriers to the acquisition and use of data. Synthetic medical data (SMD) is AI-generated data that mimics real patient information. SMD is being promoted as an ethical solution that preserves privacy while enabling scalable model training. However, as we will show, the use of SMD raises its own set of issues. SMD’s emphasis on privacy and scalability subtly embeds ethical and epistemic trade-offs that undermine the principles commonly regarded as being paramount in medical ethics. These trade-offs lack the kind of ethical justification one would expect in decisions that disrupt commonly accepted values and priorities, such as those captured by Beauchamp and Childress’ four principles. In the discourse on the ethical advantages of SMD, privacy tends to be treated as a value in its own right. We show that this is a problematic assumption. Transparency, privacy, scalability, and fidelity are all linked in complex ways with the principles of medical ethics. We map these relationships and show that when privacy is privileged over other values, it conflicts with autonomy and beneficence. Our aim here is not to establish that this privileging is wrong per se, but to show that it needs careful analysis before we can accept the idea that SMD is indeed ethically advantageous.Keywords
Funding Information
- Universitetet i Oslo
This publication has 44 references indexed in Scilit:
- Endoscopist deskilling risk after exposure to artificial intelligence in colonoscopy: a multicentre, observational studyThe Lancet Gastroenterology & Hepatology, 2025
- Fidelity-agnostic synthetic data generation improves utility while retaining privacyPatterns, 2025
- Unraveling the Regimes of Synthetic Data Metrics: Expectations, Ethics, and PoliticsDigital Society, 2025
- On the fidelity versus privacy and utility trade-off of synthetic patient dataiScience, 2025
- Synthetic data in medicine: Legal and ethical considerations for patient profilingComputational and Structural Biotechnology Journal, 2025
- Correction: Conceptual scaffolding for the philosophy of medicineMedicine, Health Care and Philosophy, 2024
- Synthetic Health Data: Real Ethical Promise and PerilHastings Center Report, 2024
- The Inviscid Limit of Navier–Stokes Equations for Locally Near Boundary Analytic Data on an Exterior Circular DomainCommunications in Mathematical Physics, 2024
- DataSifterText: Partially Synthetic Text Generation for Sensitive Clinical NotesJournal of Medical Systems, 2022
- Pair-copula constructions of multiple dependenceInsurance: Mathematics and Economics, 2009