Abstract
In this systematic review, the authors compared the methodology of studies on postoperative cognitive decline (POCD) to the criteria published in the Statement of Consensus on Assessment of Neurobehavioral Outcomes After Cardiac Surgery. This Consensus Statement has been published by Murkin et al. in 1995 {1} with the aim to improve the quality of POCD studies. Results of this review show that more than 8,000 studies have been published after the Consensus Statement. Only 274 studies used baseline cognitive testing and followed up with patients for at least 1 month. The authors could identify more than 250 different cognitive tests and a large variety of diagnostic rules. The study findings reveal that numerous studies have been published but that the majority of studies show poor compliance with the Consensus Statement. Therefore, the results of studies are difficult to interpret. The authors provide suggestions on how to improve methodology on POCD studies for the future.