Surgical interventions for age-related cataract
Authors:
- 18 October 2006
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Wiley in Cochrane Database of Systematic Reviews
- Vol. 2006 (4) , CD001323
Abstract
Cataract accounts for 50% of blindness globally and remains the leading cause of visual impairment in all regions of the world, despite improvements in surgical outcomes (WHO 2005). This number is expected to rise due to an aging population and increase in life expectancy. Although cataracts are not preventable, their surgical treatment is one of the most cost‐effective interventions in healthcare. To compare the effects of different surgical interventions for age‐related cataract. We searched CENTRAL, MEDLINE, EMBASE up to July 2006, NRR Issue 3 2005, the reference lists of identified trials and we contacted investigators and experts in the field for details of published and unpublished trials. We included randomised controlled trials (RCTS). Two review authors independently extracted data and discrepancies were resolved by discussion. Where appropriate, risk ratios, odds ratios and weighted mean differences were summarised after assessing heterogeneity between the studies. We identified 17 trials that randomised a total of 9627 people. Phacoemulsification gave a better visual outcome than extracapsular surgery but similar average cost per procedure in Europe but not in poorer countries. Extracapsular surgery with posterior chamber lens implant and ICCE with or without an anterior chamber intraocular lens (IOL) implant gave acceptable visual outcomes but extracapsular surgery had less complications. Manual small incision surgery provides better visual outcome than ECCE but slightly inferior unaided visual acuity compared to phacoemulsification. This review provides evidence from seven RCTs that phacoemulsification gives a better outcome than ECCE with sutures. We also found evidence that ECCE with a posterior chamber lens implant provides better visual outcome than ICCE with aphakic glasses. The long term effect of posterior capsular opacification (PCO) needs to be assessed in larger populations. The data also suggests that ICCE with an anterior chamber lens implant is an effective alternative to ICCE with aphakic glasses, with similar safety. Phacoemulsification provides the best visual outcomes but will only be accessible to the poorer countries if the cost of phacoemulsification and foldable IOLs decrease. Manual small incision cataract surgery provides early visual rehabilitation and comparable visual outcome to PHACO. It has better visual outcomes than ECCE and can be used in any clinic that is currently carrying out ECCE with IOL. Further research from developing regions are needed to compare the cost and longer term outcomes of these procedures e.g. PCO and corneal endothelial cell damage. 老化性白內障的外科治療 儘管外科療效有所進步,全球約50%的視盲仍舊是由白內障所致,它同時也一直是世界上所有地區視覺損傷的主要原因。(世界衛生組織2005). 由於人口老化與預期壽命延長,這個數字預計仍會增加。雖然白內障不可預防,但是手術仍是在健康照護中最具成本效益的治療方式。 比較老化性白內障的不同外科治療的療效。 我們搜尋了CENTRAL, MEDLINE, EMBASE up to July 2006, NRR Issue 3 2005,以及所找到的試驗的參考文獻,並與此領域的研究人員及專家接洽以了解已發表和未發表過的試驗細節。 我們納入了隨機對照臨床試驗。 兩位回顧作者分別擷取資料,並在有所不一致時以討論的方式解決。在檢視各研究間的差異性後,risk ratios、odds ratios以及加權後的平均數差都在適當的地方有所總結。 我們找到了共隨機分配了9627位病患的17個臨床試驗。Phacoemulsification比extracapsular手術提供較好的視覺結果。在歐洲,兩者的平均單一療程費用是相似的,但在較窮的國家則不然。 加posterior chamber lens 植入的Extracapsular手術與植入或不植入anterior chamber intraocular lens(IOL)的ICCE手術都能達到可接受的視覺結果,但是extracapsular手術有較少的併發症。手工小切口手術比ECCE提供較佳的視覺結果,但是與phacoemulsification相比,則造成略差的裸視視力。 這篇回顧根據7個隨機控制試驗結果,與ECCE合併縫合相比較,phacoemulsification 提供更好的結果。我們也發現ECCE 合併posterior chamber lens種植比ICCE合併aphakic glasses提供更好的視覺結果。posterior capsular opacification(PCO)的長期效果需要更多的人口來研究。數據也顯現,與ICCE合併aphakic glasses相較,ICCE合併 anterior chamber lens種植也是一個有效的替代選擇,且一樣安全。phacoemulsification 提供最好的視覺結果,但是如果費用能降低, Phacoemulsification和摺疊式的IOLs將更易被較窮國家引用。相較於PHACO,手工小切口白內障手術提供較快的視覺恢復和可接受的視覺結果,與ECCE相比較,它有更好視覺結果,且可以被目前正在進行的ECCE 合併IOL之任何門診部裡使用。發展中地區需要進一步研究來比較不同手術方法的費用和長期結果。(例如:PCO與角膜內皮細胞損害) 本摘要由高雄榮民總醫院葉宣德翻譯。 此翻譯計畫由臺灣國家衛生研究院(National Health Research Institutes, Taiwan)統籌。...This publication has 77 references indexed in Scilit:
- Cataract blindness and visual outcome of cataract surgery in a tribal area in PakistanBritish Journal of Ophthalmology, 2006
- A comparison of anterior and posterior chamber lenses after cataract extraction in rural Africa: a within patient randomised trialBritish Journal of Ophthalmology, 2004
- Extracapsular cataract surgery compared with manual small incision cataract surgery in community eye care setting in western India: a randomised controlled trialBritish Journal of Ophthalmology, 2003
- Outcomes of extracapsular surgery in eye camps of eastern NepalBritish Journal of Ophthalmology, 2001
- Long term clinical outcome of a randomised controlled trial of anterior chamber lenses after high volume intracapsular cataract surgeryBritish Journal of Ophthalmology, 2001
- Is anterior chamber lens implantation after intracapsular cataract extraction safe in rural black patients in Africa? A pilot study in KwaZulu-Natal, South AfricaEye, 1998
- The South Asian Cataract Management Study. I. The first 662 cataract surgeries: a preliminary report.British Journal of Ophthalmology, 1995
- Vergleich der Komplikationen nach intra- und extrakapsulärer Kataraktextraktion mit Linsenimplantation - Ergebnisse einer prospektiven, randomisierten, klinischen StudieKlinische Monatsblätter für Augenheilkunde, 1993
- 3.8 million blinded by cataract each year: projections from the first epidemiological study of incidence of cataract blindness in India.British Journal of Ophthalmology, 1990
- Cataract surgery: interim results and complications of a randomised controlled trial. Oxford Cataract Treatment and Evaluation Team (OCTET).British Journal of Ophthalmology, 1986