We compare and contrast extensions of the classical rational model of commodity pricing due to Pindyck (1993), on the occasion of the 30-year anniversary of this seminal article. The extensions we consider admit time-varying discount rates, investors' heterogeneity or both. Heterogeneous investors differ in terms of either horizon or rationality. For this comparison, we examine a total of 15 commodities covering agriculture, softs, energy and metals and a sample period from 1986 to 2022. Investors' heterogeneity proves much more important than time-varying discount rates in fitting the volatility of these commodities over this sample period.