Preventing Proteomics Data Tombs Through Collective Responsibility and Community Engagement
Authors:
Open Access
- 22 January 2026
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Springer Nature in Scientific Data
- Vol. 13 (1)
Abstract
Public proteomics repositories now host vast amounts of mass spectrometry data, yet much of it remains difficult to reuse, risking “data tombs” that are open access but not practically re-analyzable. In spring 2025, a graduate-level course at the University of Helsinki tasked six student teams with reanalyzing six projects from the Proteomics Identification Database (label-free quantification only) using a common R-based workflow (rpx, mzR, QFeatures, DEP/MSqRob2/limma/OmicsQ packages) that was shared across all teams. The teams reproduced identification, optional quantification, normalization, imputation, and differential expression analyses, and compared the outcomes to the original studies. As expected, systemic barriers recurred across cases: (i) no sample and data relationship format for proteomics metadata in any of the cases; (ii) missing details regarding decoy sets for false discovery rate assessment; (iii) proprietary-only outputs or software (e.g., Thermo.msf, Progenesis) that impeded open reanalysis in interoperable, community-standard formats; (iv) missing data-independent acquisition spectral libraries or protein sequences database files (FASTA); (v) absent or vague normalization/imputation/statistical parameters; (vi) inconsistent file naming; and (vii) insufficient biological/technical replication in at least one project. These shortcomings yielded large discrepancies in the analysis results (e.g., 13,068 vs. 4,923 proteins; 108 vs. 11 differentially expressed proteins), and, in one instance, a highlighted protein lacked robust support in the deposited identifications. We observed that reproducibility in mass spectrometry-based proteomics hinges less on instruments than on transparent metadata, open formats, and executable analysis provenance. We propose that data creators provide a minimum re-analysis package, including raw data and open formats, community standards, basic quality control summaries, data-independent acquisition spectral libraries, and complete parameter/code sets with pinned versions or containers. Moreover, we recommend repository-level nudges toward making such packages mandatory. This educational exercise simultaneously trains the students as well as stress-tests the community data practices to prevent proteomics “data tombs”.Keywords
Funding Information
- Helsingin Yliopisto (924112)
This publication has 47 references indexed in Scilit:
- Understanding Data Analysis Steps in Mass-Spectrometry-Based Proteomics Is Key to Transparent ReportingJournal of Proteome Research, 2025
- Apolipoprotein E abundance is elevated in the brains of individuals with Down syndrome–Alzheimer’s diseaseActa Neuropathologica, 2025
- Decreases in K63 Polyubiquitination in the Hippocampus Promote the Formation of Contextual Fear Memories in Both Males and FemalesHippocampus, 2024
- Standardizing Protein Corona Characterization in Nanomedicine: A Multicenter Study to Enhance Reproducibility and Data HomogeneityNano Letters, 2024
- mzIdentML 1.3.0 – Essential progress on the support of crosslinking and other identifications based on multiple spectraProteomics, 2024
- MSqRob Takes the Missing Hurdle: Uniting Intensity- and Count-Based ProteomicsAnalytical Chemistry, 2020
- Beyond Fairness and Consistency in Grading: The Role of Rubrics in Higher Education2020
- Improving Group Work Practices in Teaching Life Sciences: Trialogical LearningResearch in Science Education, 2017
- thermo-msf-parser: An Open Source Java Library to Parse and Visualize Thermo Proteome Discoverer msf FilesJournal of Proteome Research, 2011
- Exploring metaskills of knowledge-creating inquiry in higher educationInternational Journal of Computer-Supported Collaborative Learning, 2009