HRM systems between control and commitment: occurrence, characteristics and effects on HRM outcomes and firm performance
- 20 October 2014
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Wiley in Human Resource Management Journal
- Vol. 24 (4) , 424-441
Abstract
In the literature, it is often assumed that traditional, control‐oriented HRM systems are increasingly being replaced by commitment‐based HRM systems because the latter generally result in higher firm performance. However, an HRM system's effectiveness may depend on an organisation's external and internal context, and neither control nor commitment HR systems are without disadvantages. Thus, the empirical validity of this claim is not clear ex ante. This paper analyses the empirical diffusion and determinants of control and commitment HRM systems in Germany as well as their impact on HRM outcomes and firm performance. The findings indicate that between the two extreme forms of high‐control and high‐commitment HRM systems, there are two hybrid forms (long‐term‐oriented control system and regulated commitment system) that combine elements of both ‘pure’ systems. Commitment HRM systems outperform the high‐control HRM system concerning many HRM outcomes and firm performance measures. However, in direct comparison, the high and the regulated commitment HRM systems do not show substantially different outcomes, indicating that there is no one best way.Keywords
This publication has 42 references indexed in Scilit:
- The effective human resource management system in transitional China: a hybrid of commitment and control practicesThe International Journal of Human Resource Management, 2012
- Human resource management and performance: still searching for some answersHuman Resource Management Journal, 2011
- Uncovering Divergence: Management Attitudes towards HRM Practices and Works Council Presence in German SMEsEconomic and Industrial Democracy, 2009
- Human resource configurations: Investigating fit with the organizational context.Journal of Applied Psychology, 2008
- Configurations of human resource management practices: a model and test of internal fitThe International Journal of Human Resource Management, 2007
- A Conceptual Review of Human Resource Management Systems in Strategic Human Resource Management Research2006
- Strategic human resource management: integrating the universalistic, contingent, configurational and contextual perspectivesThe International Journal of Human Resource Management, 2005
- Examining the Human Resource Architecture: The Relationships Among Human Capital, Employment, and Human Resource ConfigurationsJournal of Management, 2002
- How Common is Workplace Transformation and Who Adopts it?ILR Review, 1994
- Choice of Employment Systems in Internal Labor MarketsIndustrial Relations: A Journal of Economy and Society, 1987