Lawlessness in the Federal Sentencing Process: A Test for Uniformity and Consistency in Sentence Outcomes
Authors:
- Amy L. AndersonAAAmy L. Anderson
- Cassia SpohnCSCassia Spohn
- 20 May 2009
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Justice Quarterly
- Vol. 27 (3) , 362-393
Abstract
One of the important goals of the federal sentencing guidelines was to reduce inter‐judge disparity in sentencing. In this paper, we test the assumption that structuring discretion produced uniformity in federal sentencing and consistency in the process by which judges arrive at the appropriate sentence. We also examine whether background characteristics of judges affect the sentences they impose on similarly situated offenders. We used hierarchical linear modeling, nesting the offenders in the judges that sentenced them in order to examine the sentencing decisions of federal judges in three U.S. District Courts. While we found that significant variation between judges in sentencing is largely accounted for by our level 1 characteristics, we also found that judges arrive at decisions regarding the appropriate sentence in different ways, by attaching differential weights to several of the legally relevant case characteristics and legally irrelevant offender characteristics.Keywords
This publication has 47 references indexed in Scilit:
- THE MULTILEVEL CONTEXT OF CRIMINAL SENTENCING: INTEGRATING JUDGE- AND COUNTY-LEVEL INFLUENCES*Criminology, 2006
- Sentencing Decisions in Three U.S. District Courts: Testing the Assumption of Uniformity in the Federal Sentencing ProcessJustice Research and Policy, 2005
- CONTEXTUAL DISPARITIES IN GUIDELINES DEPARTURES: COURTROOM SOCIAL CONTEXTS, GUIDELINES COMPLIANCE, AND EXTRALEGAL DISPARITIES IN CRIMINAL SENTENCING1Criminology, 2005
- RACE, ETHNICITY, THREAT AND THE LABELING OF CONVICTED FELONS*Criminology, 2005
- The Political Context of Sentencing: An Analysis of Community and Individual DeterminantsSocial Forces, 2002
- MODELING THE EFFECTS OF LEGALLY RELEVANT AND EXTRALEGAL FACTORS UNDER SENTENCING GUIDELINES: THE RULES HAVE CHANGED*Criminology, 2000
- Measuring Interjudge Sentencing Disparity: Before and After the Federal Sentencing GuidelinesThe Journal of Law and Economics, 1999
- Federal Sentencing Guidelines and Mandatory Minimum Sentences: Do Defendants Bargain in the Shadow of the Judge?The Journal of Law and Economics, 1999
- Sentencing disparity and departures from guidelinesJustice Quarterly, 1996
- The Diversification of the Federal Bench: Policy and Process RamificationsThe Journal of Politics, 1985