The Freedom to Exclude: The Case of Israeli Society
Author:
- 26 May 2016
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Cambridge University Press (CUP) in Israel Law Review
- Vol. 49 (2) , 237-266
Abstract
The phenomenon of social exclusion in Israel is a vivid demonstration of the Basic Laws' failure to fulfil their integrative role. Despite the ‘constitutional revolution’ and the Supreme Court's ongoing endeavour over the last two decades to instil a bill of rights through its jurisprudence, Israeli society has failed to fully internalise values of equality. In terms of legal jargon, individuals continue to claim and exercise ‘sole and despotic dominion’ over their private property in order to avoid contact with individuals belonging to certain minority groups. In many cases, such behaviour in the private sphere results in exclusion from the public sphere.This phenomenon is especially astonishing considering the fact that many laws in Israel apply the right of equality to the private sphere. Furthermore, the Israeli Supreme Court has developed comprehensive human rights jurisprudence applicable to the private sphere. The gap between the law in the books and the law in action illustrates that effective implementation of human rights in the private sphere cannot be achieved solely by specific legislation or by jurisprudence that is sensitive to human rights. This argument is backed by several recent bills which preserve and enforce the exclusion of minorities, particularly of Arabs, from the public sphere. These bills illustrate that exclusion is indeed a growing phenomenon in Israeli society that cannot be overlooked. Moreover, they underscore the urgent need to entrench a direct obligation to apply human rights to the private sphere at the constitutional level. This will be achieved only when Israel adopts a full constitution.Keywords
This publication has 15 references indexed in Scilit:
- Making Sense of DiscriminationRatio Juris, 2014
- “… but it has its price”: Cycles of alienation and exclusion among pioneering Druze womenInternational Journal of Educational Development, 2009
- The Limited Autonomy of Private LawThe American Journal of Comparative Law, 2008
- Contextualizing Multiculturalism: A Three Dimensional Examination of Multicultural ClaimsThe Law & Ethics of Human Rights, 2007
- The Flagbearers: Israeli Druze Women Challenge Traditional Gender RolesAnthropology & Education Quarterly, 2006
- Integration by constitutionInternational Journal of Constitutional Law, 2005
- Aging in the Shadow of the LawJournal of Aging & Social Policy, 2004
- Recognition without Ethics?Theory, Culture & Society, 2001
- Law, Politics, and the Claims of CommunityMichigan Law Review, 1992
- The History of the Public/Private DistinctionUniversity of Pennsylvania Law Review, 1982