Situating distributed cognition
Authors:
- Lisa M. OsbeckLOLisa M. Osbeck
- Nancy J. NersessianNNNancy J. Nersessian
- 19 August 2013
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Philosophical Psychology
- Vol. 27 (1) , 82-97
Abstract
We historically and conceptually situate distributed cognition by drawing attention to important similarities in assumptions and methods with those of American “functional psychology” as it emerged in contrast and complement to controlled laboratory study of the structural components and primitive “elements” of consciousness. Functional psychology foregrounded the adaptive features of cognitive processes in environments, and adopted as a unit of analysis the overall situation of organism and environment. A methodological implication of this emphasis was, to the extent possible, the study of cognitive and other processes in the natural (real world) contexts in which they occur. We therefore emphasize commonalities and differences between functional psychology and D-Cog. One purpose of the comparison is to consider the extent to which criticisms directed at functional psychology are relevant to D-Cog. We also examine the relation between functional psychology and philosophical pragmatism and conclude that D-Cog's conceptual framework would be strengthened through more explicit adoption of philosophical pragmatism, consistent with the eventual trajectory of functional psychology.Keywords
This publication has 38 references indexed in Scilit:
- Engineering Concepts: The Interplay between Concept Formation and Modeling Practices in Bioengineering SciencesMind, Culture, and Activity, 2012
- The Affordances for Social Psychology of the Ecological Approach to Social KnowingTheory & Psychology, 2007
- How a Cockpit Remembers Its SpeedsCognitive Science, 1995
- Cognition as the Cooperative Appropriation of AffordancesEcological Psychology, 1991
- Orientation in the white ratJournal of Comparative Neurology and Psychology, 1908
- A reconciliation between structural and functional psychology.Psychological Review, 1906
- Review of The Relation of Structural and Functional Psychology to Philosophy.Psychological Bulletin, 1904
- The Relations of Structural and Functional Psychology to PhilosophyPhilosophical Review, 1903
- Structural and Functional PsychologyPhilosophical Review, 1899
- Studies from the psychological laboratory of the University of Chicago: I. Reaction-time: A study in attention and habit.Psychological Review, 1896