Lexicographic preference in biodiversity valuation: Tests of inconsistencies and willingness to pay
Authors:
- 1 March 2006
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Journal of Environmental Planning and Management
- Vol. 49 (2) , 167-180
Abstract
Previous contingent valuation (CV) studies on biodiversity have indicated that as much as one-quarter of the respondents show lexicographic preferences when facing biodiversity-money trade-offs. This behaviour is incompatible with welfare theory underlying CV, and thus questions the validity and reliability of the outcome of CV of changes in biodiversity. However, it is difficult from CV responses to distinguish between strict and modified lexicographic preferences, and those attaching a high value to biodiversity. This paper adds to the empirical evidence showing that what at first hand seems to represent strict lexicographic preferences is at most representing modified lexicographic preferences, and probably rather represent just high valuation of biodiversity. Data on both hypothetical and actual willingness to pay (WTP) from a CV study on biodiversity were used to perform tests of inconsistent attitudes to estimate the maximum share of non-compensatory preferences for biodiversity. The results show that there are very few respondents in the group that consistently state high preference for biodiversity preservation and show clear reluctance to trade-off biodiversity with other goods. However, this group also had higher WTP, both hypothetical and actual, than the reference group. This is consistent with exchange preferences and steep indifference curves. Thus, people with lexicographic preferences for biodiversity are probably less numerous than previously indicated.Keywords
This publication has 20 references indexed in Scilit:
- Measuring dispositions for lexicographic preferences of environmental goods: integrating economics, psychology and ethicsEcological Economics, 2003
- Informing and forming preferences in environmental valuation: Coral reef biodiversityJournal of Economic Psychology, 2002
- Ethical Motives and Charitable Contributions in Contingent Valuation: Empirical Evidence from Social Psychology and EconomicsEnvironmental Values, 2000
- Ecosystems, contingent valuation and ethics: the case of wetland re-creationEcological Economics, 2000
- Integrated value assessment using paired comparisonsEcological Economics, 1998
- Limits to substitution and irreversibility in production and consumption: A neoclassical interpretation of ecological economicsEcological Economics, 1997
- NON‐COMPENSATORY PREFERENCE STRUCTURES IN NON‐MARKET VALUATION OF NATURAL AREA POLICYAustralian Journal of Agricultural Economics, 1996
- Ethical Beliefs and Behaviour in Contingent Valuation SurveysJournal of Environmental Planning and Management, 1996
- Preferences, information and biodiversity preservationEcological Economics, 1995
- Choice, Expectations and MeasurabilityThe Quarterly Journal of Economics, 1954