The Effects of Competition Between Schools on Educational Outcomes: A Review for the United States
Authors:
- 1 June 2002
- journal article
- review article
- Published by American Educational Research Association (AERA) in Review of Educational Research
- Vol. 72 (2) , 279-341
Abstract
This article systematically reviews U.S. evidence from cross-sectional research on educational outcomes when schools must compete with each other. Competition typically is measured by using either the Herfindahl Index or the enrollment rate at an alternative school choice. Outcomes are academic test scores, graduation/attainment, expenditures/efficiency, teacher quality, students’ post-school wages, and local housing prices. The sampling strategy identified more than 41 relevant empirical studies. A sizable majority report beneficial effects of competition, and many report statistically significant correlations. For each study, the effect size of an increase of competition by one standard deviation is reported. The positive gains from competition are modest in scope with respect to realistic changes in levels of competition. The review also notes several methodological challenges and recommends caution in reasoning from point estimates to public policy.Keywords
This publication has 47 references indexed in Scilit:
- School Choice? Or is it Privatization?Educational Researcher, 2000
- Measuring the impact of competition in local government education markets on the cognitive achievement of studentsEconomics of Education Review, 1997
- Public education supply and student performanceApplied Economics, 1997
- Private School Enrollment and Public School PerformancePolicy Studies Journal, 1996
- Public Choice in Education: Markets and the Demand for Quality EducationPolitical Research Quarterly, 1995
- Private school enrollment and public school performance: ReplyPublic Choice, 1995
- Another look at whether private schools influence public school quality: CommentPublic Choice, 1995
- Vouchers and voting: An initial estimate based on the median voter modelPublic Choice, 1995
- The decline in the number of school districts in the U.S.: 1950?1980Public Choice, 1994
- Private school enrollment and public school performancePublic Choice, 1993