Implementation of the Comprehensive Basic Science Examination in Medicine: A Scoping Review of the Global Level
- 28 November 2025
- journal article
- review article
- Published by Springer Nature in Medical Science Educator
- Vol. 35 (6) , 3185-3206
Abstract
Background The Comprehensive Basic Science Examination (CBSE) is a widely used tool in undergraduate medical education to assess foundational knowledge in basic sciences and predict future academic performance. Despite its increasing international adoption, the extent and nature of its implementation across diverse educational contexts remain unclear. Objective This scoping review aims to synthesize the available evidence on the global implementation of the CBSE, focusing on its characteristics, assessment approaches, reported outcomes, and limitations. Methods Following the Joanna Briggs Institute (JBI) methodology and PRISMA-ScR guidelines, five databases and gray literature sources were searched. Sixteen peer-reviewed studies conducted in six countries were included. The methodological quality of the studies was evaluated using the Medical Education Research Study Quality Instrument (MERSQI). Results The CBSE was used primarily in Iran, the United States, and South Korea, either as the standardized NBME version or as institution-specific adaptations. Most implementations were summative in nature, though formative and diagnostic approaches were also reported. The CBSE showed positive correlations with academic performance indicators such as GPA and licensing exam scores (e.g., USMLE Step 1, CPIE). However, limitations included resource constraints, variability in predictive validity, lack of alignment with curricula, and heterogeneous exam structures. The average methodological quality of the included studies was moderate. Conclusions The CBSE is a promising assessment tool for evaluating medical students’ basic science knowledge and predicting academic outcomes. However, its use and effectiveness vary significantly across contexts. To optimize its implementation, institutions should consider curricular alignment, resource availability, and local validation. Further high-quality, multicenter research is needed to enhance its applicability and reliability in global medical education.Keywords
This publication has 28 references indexed in Scilit:
- Personalized adaptive learning in higher education: A scoping review of key characteristics and impact on academic performance and engagementHeliyon, 2024
- Basic science knowledge underlies clinical science knowledge and clinical problem solving: evidence from veterinary medicineAdvances in Health Sciences Education, 2024
- Medical education research study quality instrument: an objective instrument susceptible to subjectivityMedical Education Online, 2024
- Score Gains on the NBME Subject Examinations in Internal Medicine Among Clerkship Students: a Two-Year Longitudinal Study from the United Arab EmiratesMedical Science Educator, 2022
- Does a Difference Exists in Comprehensive Basic Science Examination Scores of 4-Year versus 6-Year Oral-Maxillofacial Surgery Residents?Journal of Oral and Maxillofacial Surgery, 2020
- Using the NBME® Comprehensive Subject Examinations to Assess Readiness for USMLE® Step 1 and Step 2 CK: a Comparison of US/Canadian and International Medical School StudentsMedical Science Educator, 2018
- The new why when designing mandatory medical examinationsOccupational Medicine, 2017
- Is basic science disappearing from medicine? The decline of biomedical research in the medical literatureThe FASEB Journal, 2015
- Basic Science Content in the USMLE Step 12014
- Relationship between studentsʼ performances on the NBME Comprehensive Basic Science Examination and the USMLE Step 1Academic Medicine, 1997