Tobacco smoking and gastric cancer: meta-analyses of published data versus pooled analyses of individual participant data (StoP Project)
- 1 May 2018
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Wolters Kluwer Health in European Journal Of Cancer Prevention
- Vol. 27 (3) , 197-204
Abstract
Tobacco smoking is one of the main risk factors for gastric cancer, but the magnitude of the association estimated by conventional systematic reviews and meta-analyses might be inaccurate, due to heterogeneous reporting of data and publication bias. We aimed to quantify the combined impact of publication-related biases, and heterogeneity in data analysis or presentation, in the summary estimates obtained from conventional meta-analyses. We compared results from individual participant data pooled-analyses, including the studies in the Stomach Cancer Pooling (StoP) Project, with conventional meta-analyses carried out using only data available in previously published reports from the same studies. From the 23 studies in the StoP Project, 20 had published reports with information on smoking and gastric cancer, but only six had specific data for gastric cardia cancer and seven had data on the daily number of cigarettes smoked. Compared to the results obtained with the StoP database, conventional meta-analyses overvalued the relation between ever smoking (summary odds ratios ranging from 7% higher for all studies to 22% higher for the risk of gastric cardia cancer) and yielded less precise summary estimates (SE ≤2.4 times higher). Additionally, funnel plot asymmetry and corresponding hypotheses tests were suggestive of publication bias. Conventional meta-analyses and individual participant data pooled-analyses reached similar conclusions on the direction of the association between smoking and gastric cancer. However, published data tended to overestimate the magnitude of the effects, possibly due to publication biases and limited the analyses by different levels of exposure or cancer subtypes.Keywords
This publication has 33 references indexed in Scilit:
- Meta-analysis in clinical trials revisitedContemporary Clinical Trials, 2015
- Population-based multicase-control study in common tumors in Spain (MCC-Spain): rationale and study designGaceta Sanitaria, 2015
- The Swedish mammography cohort and the cohort of Swedish men: Study design and characteristics of 2 population-based longitudinal cohortsOA Epidemiology, 2013
- A case–control study on the effect of Apolipoprotein E genotypes on gastric cancer risk and progressionBMC Cancer, 2012
- Is temperature an effect modifier of the association between green tea intake and gastric cancer risk?European Journal Of Cancer Prevention, 2010
- Combination of gastric atrophy, reflux symptoms and histological subtype indicates two distinct aetiologies of gastric cardia cancerGut, 2007
- Traditional reviews, meta-analyses and pooled analyses in epidemiologyInternational Journal of Epidemiology, 1999
- Meta-analysis Spurious precision? Meta-analysis of observational studiesBMJ, 1998
- Methods for Pooled Analyses of Epidemiologic StudiesEpidemiology, 1993
- A case‐control study of gastric cancer and diet in ItalyInternational Journal of Cancer, 1989