How Whiteness Shapes Public Narratives: A Critical Discourse Analysis of Media and the NSBA Letter
- 8 September 2025
- journal article
- Published by SAGE Publications in Educational Administration Quarterly
- Vol. 61 (5) , 843-872
Abstract
Purpose: The purpose of this paper is to explore media's discursive strategies that shaped public narratives related to the National School Boards Association's (NSBA) 2021 letter to the Biden administration (“The Letter” hereafter) and the NSBA's response following media coverage. The Letter requested federal support to address the threats and violence toward educators and district leaders occurring largely at school board meetings. Research Method: We employed critical discourse analysis and a lens of possessive investment in whiteness to examine nearly 100 national and local news articles, which were primarily conservative-leaning, and archives related to The Letter. Findings: We highlight three themes among the discursive strategies of this data, which included the misrepresentation of the term domestic terrorism, the use of war-like metaphors, and the mischaracterization of parents. We also described how these strategies likely contributed to the public backlash of the NSBA, including a declining membership, and the organization's attempt at damage control through public apologies, organizational changes, and a shift in its equity-oriented work related to racial justice. Implications for Research and Practice: These findings illustrate the importance of educational intermediary organizations and leaders to proactively engage with journalists, foreground their equity commitments in evidence-based research and expert consultation, and communicate beyond media. These findings also underscore the need for media to reconsider the content of their reporting, whose voices they emphasize and ignore, and the discursive strategies they adopt when reporting on educational issues.Keywords
Funding Information
- Spencer Foundation
This publication has 37 references indexed in Scilit:
- Exposing the White Innocence Playbook of School District LeadersEquity & Excellence in Education, 2022
- The Common Core debate on Twitter and the rise of the activist publicJournal of Educational Change, 2018
- White innocence as an investigative frame in a schooling contextCritical Studies in Education, 2017
- Corpora and Discourse Studies2015
- Grassroots for Hire2014
- Who Speaks for the Climate?2011
- Media's Impact on Educational Policies and Practices: Political Spectacle and Social ControlPeabody Journal of Education, 2007
- Media Bias and ReputationJournal of Political Economy, 2006
- Persistent media biasJournal of Public Economics, 2006
- Mediatizing educational policy: the journalistic field, science policy, and cross‐field effectsJournal of Education Policy, 2004