How do students negotiate groupwork? The influence of group norm exercises and group development norms
Open Access
- 17 April 2024
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Wiley in Journal of Engineering Education
- Vol. 113 (3) , 533-554
Abstract
Background: Group norms in engineering education groupwork are usually negotiated in an implicit and often unequal manner. Although it is regularly suggested that student groups can function better if norm negotiations are, instead, made explicit, the social dynamics of group norm exercises have remained underexplored.Purpose: We investigate how students negotiate group norms in group norm exercises, including the different understandings of groupwork that they construct and draw from to facilitate their negotiations.Method: We recorded and analyzed a sequence of three group norm exercises focused on developing a team charter, with seven participating student groups. Drawing on framing theory, we study negotiation sequences in terms of framing practices, and understandings of groupwork in terms of activity frames.Results: Our findings suggest that group norm exercises can help students to coordinate their expectations and transform previously established norms. However, they may also be approached in such a way that students are discouraged from questioning established group norms, instead resolving disagreement by simply rejecting alternative perspectives. We introduce the term “group development norms” to explain these dynamics, showing that the question of how to develop group norms is in itself a subject for negotiation.Conclusions: Providing a forum and process is neither enough to ensure reflective and equitable negotiations nor transparent and inclusive group norms. To avoid that group norm exercises simply reaffirm dominant norms, students should be provided with explicit negotiation strategies and, ideally, direct facilitation.Keywords
This publication has 63 references indexed in Scilit:
- “I just do what the boys tell me”: Exploring small group student interactions in an integrated STEM unitJournal of Research in Science Teaching, 2019
- Characterizing capstone design teaching: A functional taxonomyJournal of Engineering Education, 2019
- Identity negotiation within peer groups during an informal engineering education program: The central role of leadership‐oriented youthScience Education, 2018
- Framing negotiation: Dynamics of epistemological and positional framing in small groups during scientific modelingScience Education, 2017
- Contextual Constraining of Student Design PracticesJournal of Engineering Education, 2015
- Team Effectiveness Theory from Industrial and Organizational Psychology Applied to Engineering Student Project Teams: A Research ReviewJournal of Engineering Education, 2013
- Attending to student epistemological framing in a science classroomScience Education, 2009
- Teams that Work: Campus Culture, Engineer Identity, and Social InteractionsJournal of Engineering Education, 2006
- Articulating communities: Sociocultural perspectives on science educationJournal of Research in Science Teaching, 2001
- The Impact of Cultural Norms on Women*Journal of Engineering Education, 1996