Abstract
Objective: To quantify the number of published cleft lip repair techniques that are described in substantial detail to be reproduced. Design: PRISMA-compliant scoping review. Setting: N/A. Patients, Participants: 66 published articles. Interventions: Primary unilateral cleft lip repair. Main Outcome Measures: Data on 14 predefined steps: use of pre-surgical devices, skin design and marking, local anesthesia technique, skin dissection, muscle dissection, mucosal management, frenuloplasty/frenulum management, muscular reapproximation, nasal floor closure, vermillion closure, skin closure, alar management, rhinoplasty, and post-operative stenting. Results: Four techniques were identified as being “original”: Rose, Mirault, Hagedorn, and Millard. Millard's technique was modified the most (n = 24, 36.4%). In total, 27 (40.9%) articles reported their technique design as “straight line,” 31 (47.0%) “rotation advancement,” and 8 (12.1%) “anatomic subunit.” Skin marking design was the most detailed step with 53 (80.3%) articles; muscular dissection and re-approximation were both described in 47 (71.2%). The least reported step was frenulum management with only 1 (1.5%) described. No articles reported all 14 intra-operative steps, and only 2 (3.0%) reported 13/14 steps. Conclusions: Despite substantial modifications in cleft lip surgery, there is a paucity of in-depth descriptions of the steps of repair. For trainees, this can be a barrier to gaining understanding of lip repair. As the appetite for cleft surgery education grows globally, consistency in terminology and accuracy in describing technical steps is crucial.

This publication has 70 references indexed in Scilit: