Novel Programs, International Adoptions, or Contextual Adaptations? Meta-Analytical Results From German and Swedish Intervention Research
Open Access
- 11 April 2015
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Journal of Clinical Child & Adolescent Psychology
- Vol. 45 (6) , 784-796
Abstract
One of the major dilemmas in intervention and implementation research is adaptation versus adherence. High fidelity to an intervention protocol is essential for internal validity. At the same time, it has been argued that adaptation is necessary for improving the adoption and use of interventions by, for example, improving the match between an intervention and its cultural context, thus improving external validity. This study explores the origins of intervention programs (i.e., novel programs, programs adopted from other contexts with or without adaptation) in two meta-analytic intervention data sets from two European countries and compares the effect sizes of the outcomes of the interventions evaluated. Results are based on two samples of studies evaluating German child and youth preventative interventions (k = 158), and Swedish evaluations of a variety of psychological and social interventions (k = 139). The studies were categorized as novel programs, international adoption and contextual adaptation, with a total of six subcategories. In the German sample, after statistically controlling for some crucial methodological aspects, novel programs were significantly more effective than adopted programs. In the Swedish sample, a trend was found suggesting that adopted programs were less effective than adapted and novel programs. If these results are generalizable and unbiased, they favor novel and adapted programs over adopted programs with no adaptation and indicate that adoption of transported programs should not be done without considering adaptation.Keywords
This publication has 54 references indexed in Scilit:
- Protocol for CONSORT-SPI: an extension for social and psychological interventionsImplementation Science, 2013
- Development of a framework and coding system for modifications and adaptations of evidence-based interventionsImplementation Science, 2013
- Do Evidence-Based Interventions Work When Tested in the “Real World?” A Systematic Review and Meta-analysis of Parent Management Training for the Treatment of Child Disruptive BehaviorClinical Child and Family Psychology Review, 2013
- Tinkering with Perfection: Theory Development in the Intervention Cultural Adaptation FieldChild & Youth Care Forum, 2011
- Fidelity of implementation: development and testing of a measureImplementation Science, 2010
- A meta-analytic review of depression prevention programs for children and adolescents: Factors that predict magnitude of intervention effects.Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology, 2009
- Researchers, Practitioners, and Funders: Using the Framework to Get Us on the Same PageAmerican Journal of Community Psychology, 2008
- Implementation Matters: A Review of Research on the Influence of Implementation on Program Outcomes and the Factors Affecting ImplementationAmerican Journal of Community Psychology, 2008
- Evidence-Based Psychosocial Treatments for Ethnic Minority YouthJournal of Clinical Child & Adolescent Psychology, 2008
- Implementing evidence-based interventions in health care: application of the replicating effective programs frameworkImplementation Science, 2007