Impact of the modifiable areal unit problem in assessing determinants of emergency department demand
- 31 January 2021
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Wiley in Emergency Medicine Australasia
- Vol. 33 (5) , 794-802
Abstract
Objective: To examine the impact of the modifiable areal unit problem (MAUP) in an investigation of factors associated with ED demand in Perth, Western Australia, in 2016. Furthermore, to advocate a means of avoiding this impact.Methods: ED presentations were classified as: urgent medical, non‐urgent medical, urgent trauma or non‐urgent trauma. In each group, sex‐stratified, age‐adjusted multivariate associations with socio‐economic status and distance to the nearest ED and general practitioner (GP) were estimated. Modelling was undertaken using different sets of spatial units: Australian Bureau of Statistics (ABS) Statistical Areas Level 1 (SA1s) and numerous aggregate‐level zonations of SA1s (ABS SA2s and others).Results: Estimates obtained using the different units often varied widely: for seven (30%) of 24 strata defined by combinations of sex, ED type and covariate, the smallest and largest effect sizes differed in terms of direction; further, for 11 (65%) of the remaining 17 strata, the largest effect size was at least twice as high as the smallest. This demonstrates the MAUP's impact and that analyses based on a single set of spatial units are unreliable. To resolve the observed variation, we highlight the SA1‐level estimates.Conclusions: When formulating interventions targeting reduced ED utilisation, policy planners should be guided by evidence based on analysis of appropriate spatial units. This ideal is undermined by the widespread lack of acknowledgement of the MAUP in studies examining drivers of ED demand using spatially aggregated data. To avoid the MAUP, only estimates obtained through examining a minimal geographic unit should be relied upon.Keywords
Funding Information
- Department of Health, Disability and Ageing
This publication has 20 references indexed in Scilit:
- Incorporating geography into a new generalized theoretical and statistical framework addressing the modifiable areal unit problemInternational Journal of Health Geographics, 2019
- Planning for the future: Emergency department presentation patterns in Tasmania, AustraliaInternational Emergency Nursing, 2018
- Distance effects on the accessibility to emergency departments in PortugalSaúde e Sociedade, 2014
- Socioeconomic status of emergency department users in Ontario, 2003 to 2009Canadian Journal of Emergency Medicine, 2014
- Characteristics of Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander presentations to three Victorian emergency departmentsEmergency Medicine Australasia, 2013
- Effect of Emergency Department Crowding on Outcomes of Admitted PatientsAnnals of Emergency Medicine, 2013
- Demand at the emergency department front door: 10‐year trends in presentationsMedical Journal of Australia, 2012
- Utilization of Emergency Department in Patients With Non-urgent Medical Problems: Patient Preference and Emergency Department ConvenienceJournal of the Formosan Medical Association, 2010
- The Effect of Continuity of Care on Emergency Department UseArchives of Family Medicine, 2000
- The Accuracy Of Spatial Databases1989