Musculoskeletal examination teaching by patients versus physicians: How are they different? Neither better nor worse, but complementary
Authors:
Open Access
- 25 April 2011
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Medical Teacher
- Vol. 33 (5) , e227-e235
Abstract
Background: Musculoskeletal (MSK) complaints comprise 12–20% of primary healthcare; however, practicing physicians’ MSK physical examination (PE) skills are weak. Further, there is a shortage of specialists able to effectively teach this subject. Previous evaluations of patient educators have yielded mixed results. Aims: The aim of this study is to document how teaching by patient educators and physician tutors in MSK PE skills differs. Methods: A qualitative researcher observed, video-recorded, and took notes during preclerkship MSK PE teaching sessions given by patient educators or physician tutors. The researcher identified themes which were evaluated by collective case study methods. Results: Two patient educator and four physician groups were evaluated. The patient educators were more consistent regarding content and style than the physicians. There appeared to be a continuum in teaching organization from patient educator to novice physician tutors to experienced physician tutors. The patient educators consistently covered all major joints (physicians did not); physicians were more likely to request verbalization of actions, relate findings to history, receive questions, and use opportunistic teaching moments. Conclusions: Understanding preclerkship MSK teaching by patient educators compared to physician tutors is necessary for appropriate targeting of the existing Patient Partners® in Arthritis patient educator program and to guide the development of future MSK teaching initiatives.Keywords
This publication has 15 references indexed in Scilit:
- Deliberate Practice and the Acquisition and Maintenance of Expert Performance in Medicine and Related DomainsAcademic Medicine, 2004
- Teaching the Musculoskeletal Examination: Are Patient Educators as Effective as Rheumatology Faculty?Teaching and Learning in Medicine, 2004
- Patients teach students: partners in arthritis educationMedical Education, 1999
- Positive impact of an intervention by arthritis educators on retention of information, confidence, and examination skills of medical studentsArthritis & Rheumatism, 1998
- Meeting the Challenges of an Aging PopulationAcademic Medicine, 1997
- Pelvic examination instruction and experienceAcademic Medicine, 1996
- The use of trained patient educators with rheumatoid arthritis to teach medical studentsArthritis & Rheumatism, 1996
- What is content analysis?Medical Teacher, 1996
- Proceedings of the AAMCʼS Consensus Conference on the Use of Standardized Patients in the Teaching and Evaluation of Clinical Skills. Washington, D.C., December 3–4, 1992Academic Medicine, 1993
- An Evaluation of an Innovative Approach to Teaching the Pelvic Examination to Medical StudentsWomen & Health, 1982