Who Owns the Oil that Traverses a Boundary on the Continental Shelf in an Enclosed Sea? Seeking Answers in Natural Law through Grotius and Selden
Author:
- Melissa H. LojaMLMelissa H. Loja
- 6 November 2014
- journal article
- international law-and-practice
- Published by Cambridge University Press (CUP) in Leiden Journal of International Law
- Vol. 27 (4) , 893-911
Abstract
The principle of sovereign rights under UNCLOS countenances competition among littoral states for ownership of a common oil deposit through the unilateral exploitation of their continental shelf. This leads to conflict, wastage, and resource sterilization. However, rather than apply the principle of sovereign rights, states seem to turn to natural law principles as a more reasonable regulation of their activities on the continental shelf. Two sources of natural law principles are relevant. One source consists of a priori principles of sociableness and necessity which prescribe that, for their own preservation, states ought to act pursuant to the common good. These principles underlie energy security policies which espouse interdependence. Another source of natural law principles are international agreements and national laws in which states temper their sovereign rights and interests and recognize the co-existence of the rights and interests of other states in a common deposit. These practices constitute a posteriori intervenient or secondary law of nations, which appears similar to customary law. Adherence is not dictated by conviction that these principles are obligatory. Rather, adherence seems to be based on discernment that, while permissible under the principle of sovereign rights, unilateral appropriation is impermissible under natural law.Keywords
This publication has 9 references indexed in Scilit:
- The new legal framework for oil and gas activities near the maritime boundaries between Mexico and the U.S: comments on the Agreement between the United Mexican States and the United States of America concerning transboundary hydrocarbon reservoirs in the Gulf of MexicoThe Journal of World Energy Law & Business, 2012
- Conceptual Notes on Energy Security: Total or Banal Security?Security Dialogue, 2010
- Europe's energy security: challenges and opportunitiesInternational Affairs, 2006
- Joint Development of Common Offshore oil and Gas Deposits: “Mere” State Practice or Customary International Law?American Journal of International Law, 1999
- The Basic Concept of Joint Development of Hydrocarbon Resources on the Continental ShelfInternational Journal of Estuarine and Coastal Law, 1988
- Apportionment of an International Common Petroleum DepositInternational and Comparative Law Quarterly, 1968
- Codification and Development of International LawAmerican Journal of International Law, 1955
- Jurisdiction Over the Sea Bed and Subsoil Beyond Territorial WatersAmerican Journal of International Law, 1951
- National Sovereignty over Maritime ResourcesUniversity of Pennsylvania Law Review, 1950