Presampling, algorithm factors, and noise: Considerations for CT in particular and for medical imaging in general
Authors:
- 18 April 2005
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Wiley in Medical Physics
- Vol. 32 (5) , 1321-1334
Abstract
CT scanners acquire noisy data at discrete sample positions. Typically, a convention of how to continue these data from discrete integer positions to the continuous domain must be applied during processing. We study the properties of three typical one‐dimensional spatial domain interpolation algorithms in terms of a cost or quality factor . This figure of merit is a function of spatial resolution, data noise, and dose and is used to optimize detector design. Spatial resolution is defined as either mean square width or as the full width at half maximum of the point spread function (PSF). Our results show that a trapezoidal interpolation algorithm is optimal for the high resolution domain (relative to the detector aperture size ) and should be replaced by a triangular or Gaussian interpolation function for spatial resolutions of about or larger; these result in bell‐shaped PSFs. Assuming such a hybrid algorithm we find a 1.5‐fold increase of —this is equivalent to 50% improved dose usage—when smoothing the data to a spatial resolution of or more compared to a highest resolution reconstruction. Therefore it is advisable to use detectors of one‐third of the size of the desired spatial resolution and to compensate for the 1.5‐fold increase in by reducing dose by 33%. Under the presence of moderately sized septa (e.g., 10% of the spatial resolution element size) the benefit of optimizing still lies in the order of 30% improved dose usage; in that case the detector size should be on the order of and a dose reduction of 23% can be achieved. Again, bell‐shaped PSFs show a better tradeoff between noise and resolution for a given dose than rectangular‐shaped PSFs. The general interpretation of our results is that the degree of freedom of choosing the weighting or interpolation function for a given resolution is large for small detectors and small for large detectors. Thus systems with small have a higher potential of optimization compared to systems with large . Similarly, detector binning, which corresponds to replacing by , should be avoided. Note that the figures reported correspond to a one‐dimensional interpolation. Two‐dimensional detectors typically separate and resulting quality factors can be easily obtained by multiplication. Then, is expected to improve by a factor of without septa and by a factor of with septa. This indicates that dose can be reduced by about 56% and about 41%, respectively. Our findings are general and not restricted to CT. They can be readily applied to medical or nonmedical imaging devices and digital detectors and they may also turn out to be useful in other fields.Keywords
This publication has 11 references indexed in Scilit:
- Nonuniform Noise Propagation by Using the Ramp Filter in Fan-Beam Computed TomographyIEEE Transactions on Medical Imaging, 2004
- Favorable noise uniformity properties of Fourier‐based interpolation and reconstruction approaches in single‐slice helical computed tomographyMedical Physics, 2002
- A simple theorem relating noise and patient dose in computed tomographyMedical Physics, 1999
- Optimal noise control in and fast reconstruction of fan‐beam computed tomography imageMedical Physics, 1999
- Signal-to-noise optimization of medical imaging systemsJournal of the Optical Society of America A, 1999
- Analysis of x-ray computed tomography images using the noise power spectrum and autocorrelation functionPhysics in Medicine & Biology, 1984
- On the Optimality of the Filtered Backprojection AlgorithmJournal of Computer Assisted Tomography, 1980
- Noise Limitations in X-Ray Computed TomographyJournal of Computer Assisted Tomography, 1978
- Noise Due to Photon Counting Statistics in Computed X-Ray TomographyJournal of Computer Assisted Tomography, 1977
- Statistical limitations in x‐ray reconstructive tomographyMedical Physics, 1976