Methodological components, structure, and quality assessment tools for evidence summaries: a scoping review
- 29 August 2024
- journal article
- Published by Wolters Kluwer Health in JBI Evidence Synthesis
- Vol. 23 (3) , 493-516
Abstract
Objective: The objective of this review was to identify and map the available information related to the definition, structure, and core methodological components of evidence summaries, as well as to identify any indicators of quality. Introduction: Evidence summaries offer a practical solution to overcoming some of the barriers present in evidence-based health care, such as lack of access to evidence at the point of care, and the knowledge and expertise to evaluate the quality and translate the evidence into clinical decision-making. However, lack of transparency in reporting and inconsistencies in the methodology of evidence summary development have previously been cited and pose problems for end users (eg, clinicians, policymakers). Inclusion criteria: Any English-language resource that described the methodological development or appraisal of an evidence summary was included. Methods: PubMed, Embase, and CINAHL (EBSCOhost) were systematically searched in November 2019, with no limits on the search. The search was updated in June 2021 and January 2023. Gray literature searches and pearling of references of included sources were also conducted at the same time as the database searches. All resources (ie, articles, papers, books, dissertations, reports, and websites) were eligible for inclusion in the review if they evaluated or described the development or appraisal of an evidence summary methodology within a point-of-care context and were published in English. Literature reviews (eg, systematic reviews, rapid reviews)—including summaries of evidence on interventions or health care activities that measure effects, a phenomenon of interest, or where the objective was the development, description, or evaluation of methods without a clear point-of-care target—were excluded from the review. Results: A total of 76 resources (n = 56 articles from databases and n = 20 reports from gray literature sources) were included in the review. The most common type/name of resource included critically appraised topic (n = 18) and evidence summary (n = 17). A total of 25 resources provided a definition of an evidence summary: commonalities included a clinical question; a structured, systematic literature search; a description of literature selection; and appraisal of evidence. Of these 25 resources, 16 included descriptors such as brief, concise, rapid, short, succinct , and snapshot . The reported methodological components closely reflected the definition results, with the most reported methodological components being a systematic, multi-database search, and critical appraisal. Evidence summary examples were mostly presented as narrative summaries and usually included a reference list, background or clinical context, and recommendations or implications for practice or policy. Four quality assessment tools and a systematic review of tools were included. Conclusions: The findings of this review highlight the wide variability in the definition, language, methodological components, and structure used for point-of-care resources that met our definition of an evidence summary. This scoping review is one of the first stjpg aimed at improving the credibility and transparency of evidence summaries in evidence-based health care, with further research required to standardize the definitions and methodologies associated with point-of-care resources and accepted tools for quality assessment. Supplemental digital content: A Chinese-language version of the abstract of this review is available at http://links.lww.com/SRX/A79; a list of studies ineligible following full-text review is available at http://links.lww.com/SRX/A60.Keywords
This publication has 85 references indexed in Scilit:
- Declining Quality of Systematic Reviews in Orthopaedic Sports Medicine: An Updated Systematic ReviewArthroscopy, Sports Medicine, and Rehabilitation, 2022
- Cochrane Rapid Reviews Methods Group offers evidence-informed guidance to conduct rapid reviewsJournal of Clinical Epidemiology, 2021
- Defining Rapid Reviews: a systematic scoping review and thematic analysis of definitions and defining characteristics of rapid reviewsJournal of Clinical Epidemiology, 2021
- Rapid review methods more challenging during COVID-19: commentary with a focus on 8 knowledge synthesis stepsJournal of Clinical Epidemiology, 2020
- Making the Best Clinical Decisions for PatientsDental Clinics of North America, 2019
- Improving the conduct of systematic reviews: a process mining perspectiveJournal of Clinical Epidemiology, 2018
- Living systematic review: 1. Introduction—the why, what, when, and howJournal of Clinical Epidemiology, 2017
- Dutch evidence statement for pelvic physical therapy in patients with anal incontinenceInternational Urogynecology Journal, 2014
- The development of an evidence based resource for burns careBurns, 2013
- Towards evidence-based medicine in surgical practice: Best BETsInternational Journal of Surgery, 2011