Disciplinary behaviour management strategies in schools and their impact on student psychosocial outcomes: A systematic review
Open Access
- 1 July 2024
- journal article
- review article
- Published by National Institute for Health and Care Research in NIHR Open Research
- Vol. 4, 13
Abstract
Background Disciplinary behaviour management strategies are implemented in schools to manage pupil behaviour. There is limited evidence of their intended impact on behaviour but there is growing concern around the potential negative impacts on pupil wellbeing. Methods We carried out a systematic review to examine the impact of these strategies on psychosocial outcomes in pupils (PROSPERO Registration: CRD42021285427). We searched multiple sources and double-screened titles, abstracts, and full texts. Data extraction and risk of bias assessment were done by one reviewer and checked by another. Results were narratively synthesised. Results We included 14 studies, from 5375 citations, assessing temporary suspension (n=10), verbal reprimand (n=2), and mixed strategies (n=2). Depression was the most common outcome (n=7), followed by academic grades (n=4) and behaviour in class (n=4). All except one study were at high risk of bias. We found a recurring pattern in the evidence of disciplinary strategies associated with poor mental wellbeing and behaviour in pupils. The effect on academic attainment was unclear. Conclusions Disciplinary behaviour management strategies may have negative impact on pupil mental wellbeing and class behaviour. These important consequences should be assessed in better designed studies before these strategies are implemented.Keywords
Funding Information
- National Institute for Health and Care Research Applied Research Collaboration West (NIHR200181)
This publication has 35 references indexed in Scilit:
- Systematic Review of School-Wide Trauma-Informed ApproachesJournal of Child & Adolescent Trauma, 2020
- Updating and expanding systematic reviews and meta‐analyses on the effects of school‐wide positive behavior interventions and supportsPsychology in the Schools, 2020
- Levels of problem behaviours and risk and protective factors In suspended and non-suspended studentsEducational and Developmental Psychologist, 2019
- The association between experiences of exclusionary discipline and justice system contact: A systematic reviewAggression and Violent Behavior, 2018
- The relationship between exclusion from school and mental health: a secondary analysis of the British Child and Adolescent Mental Health Surveys 2004 and 2007Psychological Medicine, 2017
- Mental Health and Educational Experiences Among Black Youth: A Latent Class AnalysisJournal of Youth and Adolescence, 2017
- Multilevel risk factors and developmental assets for internalizing symptoms and self-esteem in disadvantaged adolescents: Modeling longitudinal trajectories from the Rural Adaptation ProjectDevelopment and Psychopathology, 2014
- Externalizing and Internalizing Symptoms2011
- Zero tolerance, zero evidence: An analysis of school disciplinary practiceNew Directions for Youth Development, 2001
- School stress, teachers’ abusive behaviors, and children’s coping strategiesChild Abuse & Neglect, 2000