The relative effectiveness of different grassland restoration methods: A systematic literature search and meta‐analysis
Open Access
- 11 April 2023
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Wiley in Ecological Solutions and Evidence
- Vol. 4 (2)
Abstract
Active grassland restoration has gained importance in mitigating the dramatic decline of farmnland biodiversity. While there is evidence that such operations are generally effective in promoting plant diversity, little is known about the effectiveness of the different methods applied. Restoration methods can differ in intensity of seed bed preparation, seed source and method of seed application. In this systematic literature search and meta‐analysis, we screened the literature for studies of the restoration of mesic grasslands in temperate Europe. We focused on active restoration experiments that included a treatment and lasted for more than 3 years. We evaluated the influence of restoration factors on plant species richness relative to non‐restored controls. We found 187 articles that investigated the outcome of operations aimed at actively restoring mesic temperate grasslands. Most articles focused on plants, with only 9.6% dealing with other organisms (e.g. beetles, pollinating insects). Many papers had to be excluded due to incomplete data, too short study duration and/or lack of an adequate control. This resulted in 13 articles fulfilling our criteria for inclusion, yielding a total of 56 data points for the meta‐analysis. Restoration actions increased plant species richness by, on average, 17.4%, compared to controls. The seed source explained a significant amount of variation in plant species richness: seeds originating from a speciose donor grassland had a positive effect. This effect was even enhanced when combined with a commercial seed mix, whereas commercial seed mixes alone had no significant effect. We did not observe any effect of other factors, such as the type of seed bed preparation or the seed application method. A seed‐source obtained from species‐rich grasslands seems to be key to efficient grassland restoration in mesic grasslands of temperate Europe. Even though seeds from a speciose donor grassland should be preferred over commercial seeds, associating natural and commercial seed mixes increases plant species richness. This systematic literature search further revealed two major research gaps in grassland restoration ecology: a deficit in long‐term investigations as well as a deficit in studies focusing on non‐plant organisms.Keywords
Funding Information
- Association Nationale de la Recherche et de la Technologie (2017/0478)
- CAB International
- Schweizerischer Nationalfonds zur Förderung der Wissenschaftlichen Forschung (31003A_172953)
This publication has 50 references indexed in Scilit:
- Biodiversity of Palaearctic grasslands: a synthesisAgriculture, Ecosystems & Environment, 2014
- Restoration of grasslands on ex-arable land using regional and commercial seed mixtures and spontaneous succession: Successional trajectories and changes in species richnessAgriculture, Ecosystems & Environment, 2014
- Origin and history of grasslands in Central Europe – a reviewGrass and Forage Science, 2013
- Limiting factors in the restoration of UK grassland beetle assemblagesBiological Conservation, 2012
- Grassland restoration in practice: Do we achieve the targets? A case study from Saxony-Anhalt/GermanyEcological Engineering, 2011
- New nature by sowing? The current state of species introduction in grassland restoration, and the road aheadJournal for Nature Conservation, 2010
- Species introduction in restoration projects – Evaluation of different techniques for the establishment of semi-natural grasslands in Central and Northwestern EuropeBasic and Applied Ecology, 2010
- Ecological impacts of early 21st century agricultural change in Europe – A reviewJournal of Environmental Management, 2009
- Seed bank development after the restoration of alluvial grassland via transfer of seed-containing plant materialBiological Conservation, 2009
- Occurrence of meadow herbs in sown and unsown ploughed strips in cultivated grasslandActa Agriculturae Scandinavica, Section B — Soil & Plant Science, 2008