Sensitivity analysis of relative worth in quality function deployment matrices
Authors:
- 9 August 2012
- journal article
- Published by SAGE Publications in Concurrent Engineering
- Vol. 20 (3) , 195-202
Abstract
This article investigates how sensitive relative worth of product requirements in quality function deployment (QFD) is to different rating scales and/or worth-calculation methods used. The two most popular rating scales and worth-calculation scales are identified from the data of 295 QFD matrices published in conference and journal articles (called empirical QFD), and the sensitivity of relative worth in these empirical QFD (measured by probabilities of large changes of relative worth) is studied by switching rating scales and/or worth-calculation methods. The results suggest that relative worth does not significantly change when a worth-calculation method is fixed. In contrast, if a worth-calculation method is changed, large changes may occur. These large changes are more likely in QFD relationship matrices with small numbers of rows and columns less than or equal to six. These results may imply that designers need to commit to a worth-calculation method when they use information from QFD to make their design decisions. If designers commit to a worth-calculation method, any design decisions made based on relative worth are less likely to be impacted from the use of a rating scale.Keywords
This publication has 11 references indexed in Scilit:
- A Grey Relation Approach to the Integrated Process of QFD and QEConcurrent Engineering, 2011
- Limitations of the House of Quality to provide quantitative design informationInternational Journal of Quality & Reliability Management, 2008
- A Strategy for Managing Customer-oriented Product DesignConcurrent Engineering, 2006
- Application of Function Deployment Model in Decision Making for New Product DevelopmentConcurrent Engineering, 2006
- Integrating Target Costing Into Perception-Based Concept Evaluation of Complex and Large-Scale Systems Using Simultaneously Decomposed QFDJournal of Mechanical Design, 2006
- Improving the use of QFD with Axiomatic DesignConcurrent Engineering, 2005
- Design Parameter Estimation using a Modified QFD Method to Improve Customer PerceptionConcurrent Engineering, 2005
- Strategic planning using QFDInternational Journal of Quality & Reliability Management, 2005
- A concurrent function deployment technique for a workgroup-based engineering design processJournal of Engineering Design, 2000
- ON HOW TO PRIORITIZE DESIGN REQUIREMENTS DURING THE QFD PLANNING PROCESSIIE Transactions, 1993