Seismic Resilience and Sustainability: A Comparative Analysis of Steel and Reinforced Structures
Open Access
Abstract
This study presents a comprehensive comparative analysis of seismic resilience and sustainability between steel and reinforced concrete structures. With growing demand for environmentally responsible and disaster-resilient infrastructure, evaluating the life cycle performance of construction materials has become critical. Three building typologies—10-, 20-, and 30-story residential structures—are analyzed using a life cycle assessment (LCA), life cycle costing (LCC), and incremental dynamic analysis (IDA) to assess environmental, economic, and seismic performance. The results reveal that reinforced concrete structures tend to exert greater environmental impacts, particularly in categories such as carcinogenic emissions, ecotoxicity, and acidification, primarily due to cement production. Steel structures, while associated with higher energy consumption and mineral resource depletion, demonstrated superior seismic performance across all building heights, characterized by a greater level of ductility and collapse capacity. For instance, the 30-story reinforced concrete structure generated approximately 6.93 million kg CO2 eq, compared to 6.79 million kg CO2 eq for its steel counterpart. Steel structures, while associated with higher energy consumption and mineral resource depletion, demonstrated superior seismic performance across all building heights, sustaining up to a 15% greater spectral acceleration before collapse. Additionally, the LCC analysis showed that reinforced concrete is more cost-effective in high-rise construction, especially during the construction stage. These findings offer valuable insights for engineers and decision makers aiming to balance sustainability and structural performance in urban development.Keywords
This publication has 55 references indexed in Scilit:
- Destructive impact of successive high magnitude earthquakes occurred in Türkiye’s Kahramanmaraş on February 6, 2023Bulletin of Earthquake Engineering, 2024
- Review of visualising LCA results in the design process of buildingsBuilding and Environment, 2021
- Progress in sustainable structural engineering: a reviewInnovative Infrastructure Solutions, 2021
- A comparative life cycle assessment (LCA) of concrete and steel-prefabricated prefinished volumetric construction structures in MalaysiaEnvironmental Science and Pollution Research, 2020
- A review of life cycle assessment of buildings using a systematic approachBuilding and Environment, 2019
- Integration of LCA and LCC analysis within a BIM-based environmentAutomation in Construction, 2019
- Challenge clusters facing LCA in environmental decision-making—what we can learn from biofuelsThe International Journal of Life Cycle Assessment, 2015
- Life cycle assessment (LCA) applied to the process industry: a reviewThe International Journal of Life Cycle Assessment, 2012
- Incremental dynamic analysisEarthquake Engineering & Structural Dynamics, 2001
- Life-cycle energy use in office buildingsBuilding and Environment, 1996