Fairness as Appropriateness
Authors:
- 10 February 2009
- journal article
- Published by SAGE Publications in Science, Technology, & Human Values
- Vol. 34 (5) , 573-606
Abstract
Epistemological differences fuel continuous and frequently divisive debates in the social sciences and the humanities. Sociologists have yet to consider how such differences affect peer evaluation. The empirical literature has studied distributive fairness, but neglected how epistemological differences affect perception of fairness in decision making. The normative literature suggests that evaluators should overcome their epistemological differences by ‘‘translating’’ their preferred standards into general criteria of evaluation. However, little is known about how procedural fairness actually operates. Drawing on eighty-one interviews with panelists serving on five multidisciplinary fellowship competitions in the social sciences and the humanities, we show that (1) Evaluators generally draw on four epistemological styles to make arguments in favor of and against proposals. These are the constructivist, comprehensive, positivist, and utilitarian styles; and (2) Peer reviewers define a fair decision-making process as one in which panelists engage in ‘‘cognitive contextualization,’’ that is, use epistemological styles most appropriate to the field or discipline of the proposal under review.Keywords
This publication has 29 references indexed in Scilit:
- For Public SociologyAmerican Sociological Review, 2005
- What is Originality in the Humanities and the Social Sciences?American Sociological Review, 2004
- The Study of Boundaries in the Social SciencesAnnual Review of Sociology, 2002
- Les marchés du travail universitaires, comme économie de la qualitéRevue Française de Sociologie, 1996
- Is Science a Public Good? Fifth Mullins Lecture, Virginia Polytechnic Institute, 23 March 1993Science, Technology, & Human Values, 1994
- New Light on Old Boys: Cognitive and Institutional Particularism in the Peer Review SystemScience, Technology, & Human Values, 1991
- Emotion Work, Feeling Rules, and Social StructureAmerican Journal of Sociology, 1979
- Peer Review at the NSF: A Dialectical Policy AnalysisSocial Studies of Science, 1979
- Productivity, Favor, and Grants Among ScholarsAmerican Journal of Sociology, 1976
- Insiders and Outsiders: A Chapter in the Sociology of KnowledgeAmerican Journal of Sociology, 1972