Who Is Paying for Carbon Dioxide Removal? Designing Policy Instruments for Mobilizing Negative Emissions Technologies
Open Access
- 7 June 2021
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Frontiers Media SA in Frontiers in Climate
- Vol. 3
Abstract
Carbon dioxide removal (CDR) poses a significant and complex public policy challenge in the long-term. Presently treated as a marginal aspect of climate policy, addressing CDR as a public good is quickly becoming essential for limiting warming to well below 2 or 1.5°C by achieving net-zero emissions in time – including by mobilization of public and private finance. In this policy and practice review, we develop six functions jointly needed for policy mixes mobilizing CDR in a manner compatible with the Paris Agreement's objectives. We discuss the emerging CDR financing efforts in light of these functions, and we chart a path to a meaningful long-term structuring of policies and financing instruments. CDR characteristics point to the need for up-front capital, continuous funding for scaling, and long-term operating funding streams, as well as differentiation based on permanence of storage and should influence the design of policy instruments. Transparency and early public deliberation are essential for charting a politically stable course of action on CDR, while specific policy designs are being developed in a way that ensures effectiveness, prevents rent-seeking at public expense, and allows for iterative course corrections. We propose a stepwise approach whereby various CDR approaches initially need differentiated treatment based on their differing maturity and cost through R&D pilot activity subsidies. In the longer term, CDR increasingly ought to be funded through mitigation results-oriented financing and included in broader policy instruments. We conclude that CDR needs to become a regularly-provided public service like public waste management has become over the last century.Keywords
Funding Information
- Energimyndigheten
This publication has 40 references indexed in Scilit:
- Carbon accounting for negative emissions technologiesClimate Policy, 2021
- Casting a Wider Net on Ocean NETsFrontiers in Climate, 2021
- Incentivising bioenergy with carbon capture and storage (BECCS) responsibly: Comparing stakeholder policy preferences in the United Kingdom and SwedenEnvironmental Science & Policy, 2021
- Negative emissions and the long history of carbon removalWires Climate Change, 2020
- Should carbon removal be treated as waste management? Lessons from the cultural history of wasteInterface Focus, 2020
- Evaluating the efficacy and equity of environmental stopgap measuresNature Sustainability, 2020
- Beyond carbon pricing: policy levers for negative emissions technologiesClimate Policy, 2019
- Fading positive effect of biochar on crop yield and soil acidity during five growth seasons in an Indonesian UltisolScience of The Total Environment, 2018
- International law poses problems for negative emissions researchNature Climate Change, 2018
- Incentivize negative emissions responsiblyNature Energy, 2018