Accuracy of Reports of Lifetime Mental and Physical Disorders

Authors:

Abstract
A common approach to estimating the lifetime prevalence of mental disorders in population surveys is to ask participants to retrospectively recall any episodes of illness they may have experienced during their entire lifetime.1-8 Lifetime prevalence estimates, however, are potentially susceptible to recall bias and other memory distortions. With regard to depressive symptoms, for example, diminishing recall of past symptoms with time has been reported in a number of studies.9-12 Retrospective evaluation may thus substantially underestimate or overestimate the true lifetime prevalence of mental disorders. Recently, Moffitt et al13 examined the potential impact of recall bias in epidemiologic studies by comparing estimates based on 1-time retrospective reports and those based on reports over multiple interviews in the same cohort. They found that lifetime prevalence estimates based on cumulative reports were approximately 2 times higher than those based on retrospective data for a number of common mental disorders, including major depressive disorder (MDD), anxiety disorders, and alcohol or drug dependence. In another study, Regier et al14 found that lifetime prevalence estimates of major mental disorders based on the Epidemiologic Catchment Area (ECA) study obtained just 1 year apart (at waves 1 and 2) were 8% higher when estimates were based on combined data from both waves compared with wave 1 only. Likewise, Copeland et al15 reported underestimation of mental disorders at any given time as compared with prospective cumulative evaluation. Olino et al16 found higher lifetime prevalence estimates of several mental disorders ascertained prospectively compared with estimates based on siblings’ retrospective reports. The studies by Moffitt et al,13 Copeland et al,15 and Olino et al,16 however, were based on cohorts of children, adolescents, and young adults rather than adults of all ages. Furthermore, the study by Regier et al14 compared estimates based on 1 wave with those based on 2 waves conducted 1 year apart. To our knowledge, besides depression or depressive symptoms,9-12 no previous studies have examined whether the lifetime prevalence estimates of common mental disorders based on retrospective reports in midlife to late life are underestimated when compared with cumulative reports based on multiple interviews conducted over a longer period. Furthermore, no previous studies have compared lifetime prevalence estimates of common physical disorders such as diabetes mellitus and hypertension ascertained by retrospective report vs cumulative reports over an extended period. Therefore, it is unknown whether lifetime prevalence estimates of common mental disorders in middle-aged or older adults or physical disorders are underestimated in 1-time retrospective evaluation as compared with cumulative evaluation using multiple interviews. Given the significant burden imposed by mental and physical disorders, it is important to examine how accurately surveys can estimate their prevalence. It is also important to study the accuracy of retrospective reports over the adult life span extending into middle and older age because individuals experiencing long intervals between episodes of illness may be especially prone to forgetting past health problems. Furthermore, among older adults, these errors may be exacerbated by cognitive decline.

This publication has 24 references indexed in Scilit: