A recent article in Perspectives on Psychological Science (Webb & Tangney, 2022, W&T) reported a study where just 2.6% of participants recruited on Amazon’s Mechanical Turk were deemed "valid". They highlight some well-established limitations of Mechanical Turk, but their takeaways—the claims that it is "too good to be true," and that it captured "only 14 human beings … [of] N=529"—are radically misleading, yet have been repeated widely. We outline issues with how W&T handled data collection and how some design choices were unsuitable for this platform. Negative attitudes towards Mechanical Turk sometimes reflect a fundamental misunderstanding of what the platform offers and how it should be used in research. We point to substantial research from that details strategies for effective recruitment on Mechanical Turk, and key elements of experimental design for online research generally. We stress that Mechanical Turk is not suitable for every kind of study. Effective use requires specific expertise and design considerations. Like all tools used in research—from advanced hardware to specialist software—the tool itself places constraints on what you should use it for. Ultimately, high-quality data requires careful experimental design. This is the responsibility of the researcher, not the crowdsourcing platform.