A Comparison of a Centralized Versus De-centralized Recruitment Schema in Two Community-Based Participatory Research Studies for Cancer Prevention
Authors:
- Swann Arp AdamsSASwann Arp Adams
- Sue P. HeineySHSue P. Heiney
- Heather M. BrandtHBHeather M. Brandt
- Michael D. WirthMichael D. Wirth
- Samira KhanSamira Khan
- Hiluv JohnsonHJHiluv Johnson
- Lisa DavisLDLisa Davis
- Cassandra M. WineglassCWCassandra M. Wineglass
- Tatiana Y. Warren-JonesTWTatiana Y. Warren-Jones
- Tisha M. FelderTFTisha M. Felder
- Ruby F. DraytonRDRuby F. Drayton
- Briana DavisBDBriana Davis
- 3 August 2014
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Springer Nature in Journal of Community Health
- Vol. 40 (2) , 251-259
Abstract
Use of community-based participatory research (CBPR) approaches is increasing with the goal of making more meaningful and impactful advances in eliminating cancer-related health disparities. While many reports have espoused its advantages, few investigations have focused on comparing CBPR-oriented recruitment and retention. Consequently, the purpose of this analysis was to report and compare two different CBPR approaches in two cancer prevention studies. We utilized frequencies and Chi-squared tests to compare and contrast subject recruitment and retention for two studies that incorporated a randomized, controlled intervention design of a dietary and physical activity intervention among African Americans (AA). One study utilized a de-centralized approach to recruitment in which primary responsibility for recruitment was assigned to the general AA community of various church partners whereas the other incorporated a centralized approach to recruitment in which a single lay community individual was hired as research personnel to lead recruitment and intervention delivery. Both studies performed equally well for both recruitment and retention (75 and 88 % recruitment rates and 71 and 66 % retention rates) far exceeding those rates traditionally cited for cancer clinical trials (~5 %). The de-centralized approach to retention appeared to result in statistically greater retention for the control participants compared to the centralized approach (77 vs. 51 %, p < 0.01). Consequently, both CBPR approaches appeared to greatly enhance recruitment and retention rates of AA populations. We further note lessons learned and challenges to consider for future research opportunities.Keywords
This publication has 42 references indexed in Scilit:
- Operationalization of Community-Based Participatory Research Principles: Assessment of the National Cancer Institute's Community Network ProgramsAmerican Journal of Public Health, 2012
- A randomized trial of a diet and exercise intervention for overweight and obese women from economically disadvantaged neighborhoods: Sisters Taking Action for Real Success (STARS)Contemporary Clinical Trials, 2011
- Reducing Cancer Disparities Through Innovative Partnerships: A Collaboration of the South Carolina Cancer Prevention and Control Research Network and Federally Qualified Health CentersJournal of Cancer Education, 2011
- Assessing Readiness for Establishing a Farmers’ Market at a Community Health CenterJournal of Community Health, 2011
- Community-Based Participatory Research Contributions to Intervention Research: The Intersection of Science and Practice to Improve Health EquityAmerican Journal of Public Health, 2010
- Cervical cancer preventionCancer, 2010
- Effective Recruitment of Minority Populations Through Community-Led StrategiesAmerican Journal of Preventive Medicine, 2009
- Interdisciplinary, Translational, and Community-Based Participatory Research: Finding a Common Language to Improve Cancer ResearchCancer Epidemiology, Biomarkers & Prevention, 2009
- The Power and the Promise: Working With Communities to Analyze Data, Interpret Findings, and Get to OutcomesAmerican Journal of Public Health, 2008
- Cultural LeverageMedical Care Research and Review, 2007