Planning and Know-how: The Relationship between Knowledge and Calculation in Hayek's Case for Markets
Author:
- Dan GreenwoodDGDan Greenwood
- 1 July 2007
- journal article
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Review of Political Economy
- Vol. 19 (3) , 419-434
Abstract
Ludwig von Mises' calculation argument against socialism is of fundamental importance to the modern-day case for the market. Yet it is to Hayek that some Austrian-influenced theorists turn when responding to the computational models for non-market price fixing proposed by some socialists. Their reading of Hayek's epistemological argument for markets as distinct from Mises' calculation argument needs to be questioned. Hayek's emphasis upon the dispersal of knowledge across space and time is consistent with Mises' position. In spite of his philosophical critique of rationalist constructivism and his treatment of tacit knowledge, Hayek's case for the market ultimately relies upon the Misean calculation argument. Hayek's work is therefore best understood as a shift in emphasis rather than as a philosophical departure from Mises' position.Keywords
This publication has 16 references indexed in Scilit:
- The limits to participatory planning: a reply to Adaman and DevineEconomy and Society, 2005
- Money, money prices, and the socialist calculation debate2004
- Austrian Economics, Socialism and Impure Forms of Economic OrganisationReview of Political Economy, 2000
- Socialism against markets? A critique of two recent proposalsEconomy and Society, 1998
- Monetary Calculation and Mises's Critique of PlanningHistory of Political Economy, 1998
- Calculation, complexity and planning: the socialist calculation debate once againReview of Political Economy, 1993
- Reviving the Socialist Calculation Debate: A Defense of Hayek Against LangeSocial Philosophy and Policy, 1989
- Did the theory of market socialism answer the challenge of Ludwig von Mises? A reinterpretation of the socialist controversyHistory of Political Economy, 1983
- ECONOMIC CALCULATION UNDER SOCIALISM: THE AUSTRIAN CONTRIBUTIONEconomic Inquiry, 1980
- Price Formation in a Socialist CommunityThe Economic Journal, 1933