Should Institutional Conscientious Objection to Assisted Dying be Accommodated?
Author:
Open Access
- 27 May 2021
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Consortium Erudit in Canadian Journal of Bioethics / Revue Canadienne de Bioéthique
- Vol. 4 (1) , 15-20
Abstract
The contentious, topical debate about whether faith-based health care organizations should be granted accommodation on the basis of institutional conscientious objection to medical assistance is dying (MAiD) is addressed through a comparative analysis of arguments on both sides of the issue that references such relevant considerations as: claimed ‘moral-authority’, competing rights-based claims, obligations arising from patient welfare principles, formal justice, dissimilarity in consequences, and two illustrative arguments from analogy. The analysis leads to the conclusion that nonconditional accommodation on the basis of institutional conscientious objection to MAiD is not ethically acceptable in Canada. A compromise mechanism, consisting of a suggested set of pragmatic conditions, is proposed that could effectively balance the competing moral responsibilities that arise from this conclusion and a core assumption of the paper, i.e., that some dominant faith-based health institutions can legitimately request, and expect, that provincial/territorial governments pay them a measure of respect in their operational, health-care-delivery decision making because of these institutions’ long history of providing high quality, health care in Canada. It is further suggested that provincial/territorial governments only allow large, publicly funded, faith-based health care organizations to enact a conditional version of accommodation on the basis of institutional conscientious objection to MAiD in circumstances where the organization has entered into a formal agreement with the relevant health department to meet the proposed, compromise conditions (or a relevantly-similar set of conditions).Keywords
This publication has 15 references indexed in Scilit:
- No conscientious objection without normative justification: A replyBioethics, 2019
- Institutional non‐participation in assisted dying: Changing the conversationBioethics, 2018
- Medical Assistance in Dying in Canada: An Ethical Analysis of Conscientious and Religious ObjectionsBioéthiqueOnline, 2018
- Early Experience With the California End of Life Option ActJAMA Internal Medicine, 2017
- Why medical professionals have no moral claim to conscientious objection accommodation in liberal democraciesJournal of Medical Ethics, 2016
- VOICES OF DISCONTENT? CONSCIENCE, COMPROMISE, AND ASSISTED DYINGMedical Law Review, 2015
- Justification for Conscience Exemptions in Health CareBioethics, 2013
- Story Similarity in Arguments from AnalogyInformal Logic, 2012
- Taking Conscience SeriouslySSRN Electronic Journal, 2012
- Conscientious Objection in Health Care2011