Determinants of Multilevel Discourse Outcomes in Anomia Treatment for Aphasia
- 12 September 2024
- journal article
- research article
- Published by American Speech Language Hearing Association in Journal of Speech, Language, and Hearing Research
- Vol. 67 (9) , 3094-3112
Abstract
Purpose: Individuals with aphasia identify discourse-level communication (i.e., language in use) as a high priority for treatment. The central premise of most aphasia treatments is that restoring language at the phoneme, word, and/or sentence level will generalize to discourse. However, treatment-related changes in discourse-level communication are modest, are poorly understood, and vary greatly among individuals with aphasia. In response, this study consisted of a multilevel discourse analysis of archival, monologic discourse outcomes across two high-intensity Semantic Feature Analysis (SFA) clinical trials. Aim 1 evaluated changes in theoretically motivated discourse outcomes representing lexical–semantic processing, lexical diversity, grammatical complexity, and discourse informativeness. Aim 2 explored the potential moderating role of nonlanguage cognitive factors (semantic memory, divided attention, and executive function) on discourse outcomes. Method: This study was a retrospective analysis of archival monologic discourse outcomes after intensive SFA for n = 60 (Aim 1) and a subset n = 44 (Aim 2). Outcome measures included lexical–semantic processing (% semantic errors), lexical diversity (moving average type–token ratio), grammatical complexity (mean utterance length), and discourse informativeness (% correct information units). Bayesian generalized mixed-effects models were used to examine changes across four study time points: enrollment, entry, exit, and 1-month follow-up. Results: The present study found no evidence for meaningful or statistically reliable improvements in monologue discourse performance after SFA when measured using standard, general-topic discourse stimuli. There was weak and inconsistent evidence that nonlanguage cognitive factors may play a role in moderating treatment response. Conclusions: These findings indicate a clear need to pair theoretically informed treatments designed to facilitate generalization to discourse with intentional measurement paradigms designed to capture it. Furthermore, there is a clear need to examine how established treatments, restorative or compensatory, can better facilitate generalization to discourse-level communication. These priorities are critical for meaningfully improving everyday communication and reducing the profound communication and psychosocial consequences of aphasia. Supplemental Material: https://doi.org/10.23641/asha.26524081Keywords
This publication has 67 references indexed in Scilit:
- Mechanisms underlying anomia treatment outcomesJournal of Communication Disorders, 2020
- Balancing Type I error and power in linear mixed modelsJournal of Memory and Language, 2017
- Narrative discourse in anomic aphasiaNeuropsychologia, 2012
- Using Semantic Feature Analysis to Improve Contextual Discourse in Adults With AphasiaAmerican Journal of Speech-Language Pathology, 2008
- Single subject controlled experiments in aphasia: The science and the state of the scienceJournal of Communication Disorders, 2006
- Models of Impaired Lexical Access in Speech ProductionJournal of Memory and Language, 2000
- The Cognitive Representation and Processing of Discourse: Function and Dysfunction1990
- The quantitative analysis of agrammatic production: Procedure and dataBrain and Language, 1989
- The Cognitive Basis of Knowledge Transfer1987
- A spreading-activation theory of semantic processing.Psychological Review, 1975