The authors present the case of a 20-year-old male with elevated triglycerides, although with clear plasma and non-elevated lipemic index. Having identified this inconsistency, suspicion of glycerol kinase deficiency (GKD) was confirmed by demonstration of elevated plasma glycerol and the finding of a mutation in the glycerol kinase gene on chromosome Xp21. This constellation of elevated triglycerides with clear plasma and non-elevated lipemic index is important to recognize in order that elevated cardiovascular risk is not inappropriately assigned and to prevent exposure of patients to unnecessary lipid-modifying drugs. This presents an opportunity where clinical laboratories can be proactive in identifying an inconsistency between lipemic index and measured triglycerides, raising the awareness of GKD amongst clinicians and suggesting appropriate further investigations.