Is, Ought, and the Limited Competence of Experts
Author:
Open Access
- 6 December 2023
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Center for Religion, Culture and Democracy in Journal of Religion, Culture & Democracy
Abstract
The moral innovators whom C. S. Lewis criticized in *The Abolition of Man* supposed that they could draw imperatives out of their superior understanding of sentiment and instinct. They assumed that to know what human beings want to do is to know what human beings should do. But people want to do all sorts of things that are irrational, pointless, harmful, and even downright evil. And people want inconsistent things. So the innovators are incoherent. As Lewis correctly affirmed, no amount of knowledge about nature or the world is sufficient by itself to direct us to do what is good and right. "From propositions about fact alone no practical conclusion can ever be drawn," Lewis stated. To reason well, expertise is not enough. We must also know what is good, and we must be capable of exercising right judgment.Keywords
This publication has 10 references indexed in Scilit:
- Natural Law in Court2015
- Making Men Moral: Civil Liberties and Public MoralityJournal of Law and Religion, 2001
- What's Wrong with Sexual Harassment?Stanford Law Review, 1997
- Mapping the Margins: Intersectionality, Identity Politics, and Violence against Women of ColorStanford Law Review, 1991
- Race and Essentialism in Feminist Legal TheoryStanford Law Review, 1990
- Jurisprudence and GenderThe University of Chicago Law Review, 1988
- The Concept of a Legal System1980
- Pure Theory of Law1967
- A Realistic Jurisprudence -- The Next StepColumbia Law Review, 1930
- The Path of the LawHarvard Law Review, 1897