Abstract
Grubb et al. used data from 226 species from an Australian rainforest to show that the slope of the lower boundary (5% quantile) of the relation between seed mass and plant size was shallower than the slope of the upper boundary (95% quantile) (1). We believe that this is not sufficient evidence to exclude a Charnov-like explanation for the relation between seed mass and plant size or to support the mechanical-constraints hypothesis.