Digital environment or fee-based business model? Bank competitiveness in Kazakhstan
Open Access
- 3 June 2026
- journal article
- Published by LLC CPC Business Perspectives in Banks and Bank Systems
- Vol. 21 (3) , 12-29
Abstract
Type of the article: Research ArticleAbstractDigital transformation of banking is widely expected to reshape competition, but it remains unclear whether it strengthens individual banks’ competitive positions, particularly in emerging markets. This study examines how digitalization relates to bank competitiveness, distinguishing the national digital environment from banks’ fee-based business models and taking Kazakhstan – a digital frontrunner with an unusually profitable banking sector – as the focal case. A two-layer, two-way fixed-effects design is used: a cross-country panel of up to 147 economies (2004–2025), combining IMF Financial Soundness Indicators with the United Nations E-Government Development Index, and a bank-level panel of Kazakhstan’s second-tier banks (2016–2025), in which a fee-oriented business model is proxied by commission income relative to assets. Across countries, the strong negative cross-sectional association between digital maturity and bank profitability – a country-level correlation of −0.45 – disappears once fixed country differences are absorbed, as a standardized coefficient of −0.43 turns to an insignificant +0.09, revealing a development gradient rather than a competitive effect. No robust within-country effect on profitability, margins, spreads, or cost efficiency survives. Within Kazakhstan, by contrast, a one-standard-deviation increase in commission intensity is associated with a 0.7 percentage-point wider interest spread and a 0.8 percentage-point higher net interest margin (both p < 0.05). This bank-level relationship holds when the dominant digital bank is excluded and is stable in magnitude under more conservative inference, though its statistical significance weakens, indicating that the competitive returns associated with a fee-based business model led in this market by digital, platform-based banks are concentrated within markets, across banks, rather than across national aggregates.Keywords
This publication has 32 references indexed in Scilit:
- The influence of digital transformation on chinese bank profitability performancePLOS ONE, 2026
- Digital Transformation and Bank Liquidity Creation: Evidence From a Bank-Based MarketSage Open, 2025
- The Impact of Digital Transformation on Commercial Banks’ Business Performance: An Empirical Study of 39 Listed Commercial BanksSage Open, 2025
- Financial intermediation services and competition analyses: Review and paths forward for improvementJournal of Financial Intermediation, 2024
- Innovations and international competitiveness: Country-level evidenceEconomics & Sociology, 2023
- Fintech: what’s old, what’s new?Journal of Financial Stability, 2021
- Fintech and banking: What do we know?Journal of Financial Intermediation, 2020
- Digital Disruption in BankingAnnual Review of Financial Economics, 2019
- Bootstrap-Based Improvements for Inference with Clustered ErrorsReview of Economics and Statistics, 2008
- Determinants of Commercial Bank Interest Margins and Profitability: Some International EvidenceThe World Bank Economic Review, 1999