A Bayesian Ordinal Analysis of Students’ Progression Across Van Hiele Levels
Open Access
- 28 February 2026
- journal article
- Published by Universitas Bumigora in Jurnal Varian
- Vol. 9 (1) , 53-66
Abstract
Understanding students’ progression across hierarchical levels of geometric reasoning requires analytical approaches that respect ordinal structure and quantify uncertainty. The purpose of this study is to model students’ progression across Van Hiele levels probabilistically and to estimate level-specific transition probabilities under uncertainty using paired pretest–posttest data from Grade 8 and Grade 9 students. The method used in this study is Bayesian ordinal regression with a cumulative logit specification estimated via MCMC sampling. Van Hiele levels were modeled as ordered categorical outcomes, and posterior summaries, transition matrices, and posterior predictive checks were used to characterize progression and assess model adequacy. The results indicate that progression is predominantly upward in both grades, with negligible posterior support for regression. Grade-dependent differences are evident: Grade 8 shows broader, more heterogeneous transitions from a uniformly low baseline, whereas Grade 9 exhibits more constrained, incremental progression from a higher, more dispersed initial distribution. Posterior predictive checks confirm that the model adequately reproduces the observed posttest patterns, supporting the validity of the Bayesian ordinal specification. Pedagogically, these findings imply that students at lower baseline levels tend to undergo broader conceptual shifts, whereas those at higher levels require sustained, targeted instructional support to advance further. These findings indicate that baseline ordinal structure shapes progression dynamics and that Bayesian ordinal modeling offers a coherent alternative to significance-based approaches for analyzing hierarchical learning outcomes. Educationally, this underscores the need to align instruction with students’ initial Van Hiele levels to support optimal conceptual advancement.Keywords
This publication has 20 references indexed in Scilit:
- Ordinal regression models made easy: A tutorial on parameter interpretation, data simulation and power analysisInternational Journal of Psychology, 2024
- An adaptive transition probability matrix with quality seeds for cellular automata modelsGIScience & Remote Sensing, 2024
- Identifying factors associated with child malnutrition in Ghana: a cross-sectional study using Bayesian multilevel ordinal logistic regression approachBMJ Open, 2023
- How trace plots help interpret meta‐analysis resultsResearch Synthesis Methods, 2023
- A Characterization of Van Hiele’s Level 5 of Geometric Reasoning Using the Delphi MethodologyInternational Journal of Science and Mathematics Education, 2023
- Bayesian sample size planning for developmental studiesInfant and Child Development, 2023
- Application of approximate Bayesian computation for estimation of modified weibull distribution parameters for natural fiber strength with high uncertaintyJournal of Materials Science, 2022
- Music students’ experienced workload, livelihoods and stress in higher education in Finland and the United KingdomMusic Education Research, 2020
- Bayesian analysis for social data: A step-by-step protocol and interpretationMethodsX, 2020
- Towards emotion-sensitive learning cognitive state analysis of big data in education: deep learning-based facial expression analysis using ordinal informationComputing, 2019