Knowledge as Credit for True Belief
Author:
- John GrecoJGJohn Greco
- 4 September 2003
- book chapter
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP)
- p. 111-134
Abstract
This chapter argues that by attending to the illocutionary force of knowledge attributions — specifically, that they serve to give credit to the believer for getting things right — fallibilists can assuage two problems plaguing their concept of knowledge: namely, the lottery problem and the Gettier problem. Borrowing work from Joel Fienberg on blaming, an account of credit attribution is developed that stresses the relationship between causal salience and causal responsibility. Because causal salience is context sensitive, resolutions to the lottery problem and the Gettier problem contain a significant contextual element. Just as an agent must be causally responsible in order to receive credit for athletic feats, so too must an agent's cognitive character or intellectual virtue be a necessary element to explain why an agent is deserving of credit for obtaining a true belief. This account is tested against cases relative to the above problems and ends with how this account can explain the value of knowledge.Keywords
This publication has 87 references indexed in Scilit:
- What is it like to be me?Australasian Journal of Philosophy, 1998
- What Are the “Chances” of Being Justified?The Monist, 1998
- Why Should Inquiring Minds Want to Know?The Monist, 1998
- Perspectives in virtue epistemology: A response to Dancy and BonjourPhilosophical Studies, 1995
- Sosa on knowledge, justification, and aptnessPhilosophical Studies, 1995
- Supervenience, virtues and consequences: A commentary onknowledge in perspective by Ernest SosaPhilosophical Studies, 1995
- The new critique of anti-consequentialist moral theoryPhilosophical Studies, 1993
- Virtue, Praise and SuccessThe Monist, 1990
- Moore and Wittgenstein as TeachersTeaching Philosophy, 1989
- Virtue and ReasonThe Monist, 1979