Online censorship has so far been regarded as an almost exclusive domain of autocratic governance. However, there is growing empirical evidence that democracies also follow global trends towards the regulation of online content. Therefore, this chapter focuses on how democratic governments justify stricter measures of online content regulation in communicative discourses. It introduces a discourse analysis approach to reconstruct governmental legitimatory strategies and their development over time, applying it to the case of France. Its main argument is that—somewhat paradoxically—it is the recent turn towards democratic sovereignty as the main legitimatory strategy that has allowed the French government to justify stricter state regulation and to exert greater pressure on platforms with respect to their content moderation practices.