Bone age and dental age to assess criminal responsibility: Part I
- 1 March 2025
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Springer Nature in International journal of legal medicine
- Vol. 139 (4) , 1691-1705
Abstract
Introduction Age estimation in forensic science plays a crucial role in determining legal and criminal responsibilities for living individuals. When the age of an individual is uncertain, a forensic age estimation examination is required, typically involving radiographic evaluation of bone and dental development. This study aimed to estimate and classify bone and dental ages in a Portuguese population aged 6 to 21 years, using the Baccetti and Moorrees, Fanning, and Hunt methods. The results were compared to chronological age and between methods for medico-legal purposes, utilizing lateral cephalograms and orthopantomograms. Materials and methods A total of 466 lateral cephalograms and 767 orthopantomograms were analyzed. Baccetti stages were assigned to the lateral cephalograms, and cephalometric analysis was performed using ImageJ® software. For orthopantomograms, each tooth in the third quadrant was assigned a stage based on the MFH method. Results and discussion Cohen’s weighted kappa coefficients were 0.987 (intra-observer) and 0.977 (inter-observer) for the Baccetti method. Moorrees, Fanning, and Hunt method validations ranged from 0.655 to 1.00. Correlation coefficients for dental and bone regressions were 0.894 and 0.907, with adjusted determination coefficients of 0.798 and 0.822, respectively. The dental regression underestimated age, unlike the bone regression. The methods’ accuracy and reliability varied based on the age being classified. Conclusions Both regressions accurately estimated age, but the dental method was more appropriate due to its tendency to underestimate, high precision and consistency of results. No significant differences were found between males and females, and both methods, dental and bone, may be used together to classify legal ages.Keywords
This publication has 41 references indexed in Scilit:
- Dental age assessment: scoring systems and models from the past until the present—how is it presented in the court?International journal of legal medicine, 2023
- Deep focus approach for accurate bone age estimation from lateral cephalogramJournal of Dental Sciences, 2022
- Concordances and correlations between chronological, dental and bone ages: A retrospective study in French individualsForensic Science International, 2022
- Mathematically optimal decisions in forensic age assessmentInternational journal of legal medicine, 2021
- Cut-off for the legal ages in the Portuguese Population by Third Maturity Index: Measures of AccuracyArchives of Oral Biology, 2021
- Minor or adult? Introducing decision analysis in forensic age estimationScience & Justice, 2021
- Diagnostic assessment of tooth maturation of the mandibular second molars as a skeletal maturation indicator: A retrospective longitudinal studyAmerican Journal of Orthodontics and Dentofacial Orthopedics, 2020
- Sex determination in a Spanish population based on sacrumJournal of Forensic and Legal Medicine, 2018
- Comparative study on the effect of ethnicity on wisdom tooth eruptionInternational journal of legal medicine, 2007
- The Cervical Vertebral Maturation (CVM) Method for the Assessment of Optimal Treatment Timing in Dentofacial OrthopedicsSeminars in Orthodontics, 2005