Is volumetric modulated arc therapy with constant dose rate a valid option in radiation therapy for head and neck cancer patients?
- 1 May 2018
- journal article
- research article
- Published by VM Media Group sp. z o.o in Reports of Practical Oncology and Radiotherapy
- Vol. 23 (3) , 175-182
Abstract
Intensity-modulated radiotherapy (IMRT) improves dose distribution in head and neck (HN) radiation therapy. Volumetric-modulated arc therapy (VMAT), a new form of IMRT, delivers radiation in single or multiple arcs, varying dose rates (VDR-VMAT) and gantry speeds, has gained considerable attention. Constant dose rate VMAT (CDR-VMAT) associated with a fixed gantry speed does not require a dedicated linear accelerator like VDR-VMAT. The present study explored the feasibility, efficiency and delivery accuracy of CDR-VMAT, by comparing it with IMRT and VDR-VMAT in treatment planning for HN cancer. Step and shoot IMRT (SS-IMRT), CDR-VMAT and VDR-VMAT plans were created for 15 HN cancer patients and were generated by Pinnacle3 TPS (v 9.8) using 6 MV photon energy. Three PTVs were defined to receive respectively prescribed doses of 66 Gy, 60 Gy and 54 Gy, in 30 fractions. Organs at risk (OARs) included the mandible, spinal cord, brain stem, parotids, salivary glands, esophagus, larynx and thyroid. SS-IMRT plans were based on 7 co-planar beams at fixed gantry angles. CDR-VMAT and VDR-VMAT plans, generated by the SmartArc module, used a 2-arc technique: one clockwise from 182° to 178° and the other one anti-clockwise from 178° to 182°. Comparison parameters included dose distribution to PTVs (Dmean, D2%, D50%, D95%, D98% and Homogeneity Index), maximum or mean doses to OARs, specific dose-volume data, the monitor units and treatment delivery times. Compared with SS-IMRT, CDR-VMAT significantly reduced the maximum doses to PTV1 and PTV2 and significantly improved all PTV3 parameters, except D98% and D95%. It significantly spared parotid and submandibular glands and was associated with a lower Dmean to the larynx. Compared with VDR-VMAT, CDR-VMAT was linked to a significantly better Dmean, to the PTV3 but results were worse for the parotids, left submandibular gland, esophagus and mandible. Furthermore, the Dmean to the larynx was also worse. Compared with SS-IMRT and VDR-VMAT, CDR-VMAT was associated with higher average monitor unit values and significantly shorter average delivery times. CDR-VMAT appeared to be a valid option in Radiation Therapy Centers that lack a dedicated linear accelerator for volumetric arc therapy with variable dose-rates and gantry velocities, and are unwilling or unable to sanction major expenditure at present but want to adopt volumetric techniques.Keywords
This publication has 19 references indexed in Scilit:
- Static and rotational intensity modulated techniques for head-neck cancer radiotherapy: A planning comparisonPhysica Medica, 2014
- Feasibility of constant dose rate VMAT in the treatment of nasopharyngeal cancer patientsRadiation Oncology, 2014
- Feasibility study of volumetric modulated arc therapy with constant dose rate for endometrial cancerMedical Dosimetry, 2013
- Characterization of a novel 2D array dosimeter for patient‐specific quality assurance with volumetric arc therapyMedical Physics, 2013
- Radiotherapy facilities, equipment, and staffing in Poland: 2005–2011Reports of Practical Oncology and Radiotherapy, 2013
- RapidArc, SmartArc and TomoHD compared with classical step and shoot and sliding window intensity modulated radiotherapy in an oropharyngeal cancer treatment plan comparisonRadiation Oncology, 2013
- A comparison of several modulated radiotherapy techniques for head and neck cancer and dosimetric validation of VMATRadiotherapy and Oncology, 2011
- Variable dose rate single-arc IMAT delivered with a constant dose rate and variable angular spacingPhysics in Medicine & Biology, 2009
- Volumetric Intensity-Modulated Arc Therapy Vs. Conventional IMRT in Head-and-Neck Cancer: A Comparative Planning and Dosimetric StudyInternational Journal of Radiation Oncology - Biology - Physics (IJROBP), 2009
- Volumetric modulated arc therapy: IMRT in a single gantry arcMedical Physics, 2007