Reliability-based designs are presented for semi-gravity retaining walls, anchored sheet pile walls and walls with seepage in the retained fill towards a vertical drainage layer. The probabilities of failure inferred from reliability indices are compared with Monte Carlo simulations. System reliability involving multiple failure modes is illustrated. Comparisons are made with LRFD and EC7 design methods. The cases include a problem after Terzaghi et al. (1996) that requires searching for the critical quadrilateral soil wedge in both deterministic analysis and probability-based designs, and deterministic examples from Clayton et al. (2013) and Lambe and Whitman (1979) which are extended probabilistically. Insights are presented for LRFD and EC7-DA2 to resolve a paradox that arises due to segregating the active earth thrust into a destabilizing horizontal component and a stabilizing vertical component. Possible multiple outcomes in partial factor design of an anchored sheet pile wall involving stabilizing–destabilizing duality of soil unit weight are explained.