Reconsidering Anthropological Explanations of Ethnic School Failure
Author:
- 1 March 1991
- journal article
- Published by Wiley in Anthropology & Education Quarterly
- Vol. 22 (1) , 60-86
Abstract
This article reviews the anthropological debate on why some ethnic minorities fail more frequently in schools. Although neither side presents overwhelming empirical evidence, John Ogbu's caste theory is clearly a more comprehensive, systematic explanation than the “cultural difference” explanation. In addition, Ogbu's “multilevel” or macro style of school ethnography has important methodological advantages over the less historical, more decontextualized micro ethnographies of classrooms. Nevertheless, as various micro ethnographers have pointed out, caste theory has difficulty accounting for in‐group variance and the school success of some oppressed ethnic minorities. Results from a field study in South Texas are used to illustrate that Ogbu's notion of an “oppositional culture” does underestimate both in‐group variation and the self‐valorizing potential of ethnic oppositional cultures. The school‐level description of students' “dramaturgical communicative competence” demonstrates why many middle‐class Mexicanos are not held back by their ethnic oppositional culture. The article ends by advocating a model of macro school ethnography that is based on a multiple dominance view of society and a phenomenological notion of ethnic culture rather than caste theory.Keywords
This publication has 16 references indexed in Scilit:
- carne, carnales, and the carnivalesque: Bakhtinian batos, disorder, and narrative discoursesAmerican Ethnologist, 1989
- Culturally Based Explanations of Minority Students' Academic AchievementAnthropology & Education Quarterly, 1988
- Success or Failure? Learning & the Language Minority StudentThe Modern Language Journal, 1988
- “Becoming Somebody”: Central American Immigrants in U.S. Inner‐City SchoolsAnthropology & Education Quarterly, 1987
- Transformation and School Success: The Politics and Culture of Educational AchievementAnthropology & Education Quarterly, 1987
- Variability in Minority School Performance: A Problem in Search of an ExplanationAnthropology & Education Quarterly, 1987
- The Explanation of Minority School Failure, AgainAnthropology & Education Quarterly, 1987
- Gramsci's Relevance for the Study of Race and EthnicityJournal of Communication Inquiry, 1986
- Black students' school success: Coping with the ?burden of ?acting white??The Urban Review, 1986
- School Ethnography: A Multilevel Approach1Anthropology & Education Quarterly, 1981