Virtual deliberation on genetics research: report-out of key themes from Diné (Navajo) research & healthcare professionals
Authors:
Open Access
- 3 February 2026
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Springer Nature in Journal of Community Genetics
- Vol. 17 (1) , 27
Abstract
Various challenges including cultural concerns, the shortage of Diné (Navajo) scientists and scientists with cultural competence to engage with Diné communities, and the need for rigorous policies regarding genetic research led to the establishment of a moratorium on genetic research within the Navajo Nation in 2002. Previous surveys with Diné interest holders highlighted ongoing uncertainty about lifting the moratorium and underscored the need for further community consultation and education. Deliberative democratic engagement has been an effective approach for exploring Indigenous community values regarding genomic research. To assess perspectives on genetic research and inform future policy, we conducted a two-day virtual deliberation with 17 research and healthcare professionals associated with the Navajo Nation, including Diné (n = 15) and non-Diné (n = 2) deliberants. Deliberants varied in their knowledge of genetics (n = 5 reported knowing “a lot”; n = 12 “a little bit”), and a majority (n = 13) were aware of the moratorium. Two overarching themes, “life and history experiences” and “values,” emerged, reflecting how personal and professional backgrounds, alongside individual and collective standards, shaped deliberants’ views on genetic research and its practices. Subthemes within these categories offered deeper insights into their perspectives. Although deliberants expressed caution regarding exploratory genetic studies, there was interest in using genetic research to advance individualized healthcare. Deliberants’ concerns emphasized the need for a robust genetic research policy that prioritizes Diné culture, community interests, public health and wellbeing, and the sovereignty of the Navajo Nation.Keywords
Funding Information
- NIH (RM1 HG009042-03S2)
- NIH R35 Genomic Innovator Award (R35HG011319)
- NIHGRI (RM1 HG009042-04S1)
This publication has 58 references indexed in Scilit:
- The UN Declaration on the Rights of Indigenous Peoples and Genomics: Ethical Complementarity for Just ResearchHastings Center Report, 2024
- A Systematic Review Exploring Empirical Pharmacogenomics Research Within Global Indigenous PopulationsMolecular Genetics & Genomic Medicine, 2024
- Demographic Diversity of Clinical Trials for Therapeutic Drug Products: A Systematic Review of Recently Published Articles, 2017‐2022The Journal of Clinical Pharmacology, 2024
- Precision medicine research with American Indian and Alaska Native communities: Results of a deliberative engagement with tribal leadersGenetics in Medicine, 2021
- Racial and Ethnic Disparities Among Participants in Precision Oncology Clinical StudiesJAMA Network Open, 2021
- Health Disparities Research with American Indian Communities: The Importance of Trust and TransparencyAmerican Journal of Community Psychology, 2020
- Saturation in qualitative research: exploring its conceptualization and operationalizationQuality & Quantity, 2017
- Two-Eyed Seeing and other lessons learned within a co-learning journey of bringing together indigenous and mainstream knowledges and ways of knowingJournal of Environmental Studies and Sciences, 2012
- Why and When Should We Use Public Deliberation?Hastings Center Report, 2012
- What Is Public Deliberation?Hastings Center Report, 2012