A Cost-Utility Analysis of Open and Endoscopic Carpal Tunnel Release
Authors:
- 1 February 2006
- journal article
- research article
- Published by SAGE Publications in Canadian Journal of Plastic Surgery
- Vol. 14 (1) , 15-20
Abstract
Background: Open carpal tunnel release (OCTR) is the standard procedure for the surgical treatment of carpal tunnel syndrome. with the advent of minimally invasive surgery, endoscopic carpal tunnel release (ECTR) was introduced. Objective: To use a decision analytical model to compare ECTR with OCTR in an economic evaluation. Methods: Direct medical costs were obtained from a Canadian university hospital. Utility values obtained from experts, presented with carpal tunnel syndrome outcome health states, were transformed into quality-adjusted life years (QALYs). The probabilities of the health states associated with both techniques were obtained from the literature. Results: The incremental cost-utility ratio (ICUR) was $124,311.32/QALY gained, providing strong evidence to reject ECTR when ECTR is performed in the main operating room and OCTR is performed in the day surgery unit. A one-way sensitivity analysis in the present study demonstrated that when both OCTR and ECTR are performed in day surgery unit, the ICUR falls in the ‘win-win’ quadrant, making ECTR both more effective and less costly than OCTR. If the scar tenderness probability is decreased in the ECTR group in a second one-way sensitivity analysis, the ICUR decreases to $100,621.91/QALY gained, providing evidence to reject ECTR. If the reflex sympathetic dystrophy probability is increased in the ECTR group in a third one-way sensitivity analysis, the ICUR increases to $202,657.88/QALY gained, providing strong evidence to reject ECTR. Conclusions: There is still uncertainty associated with the costs and effectiveness of ECTR and OCTR. To obtain a definitive answer as to whether the ECTR is more effective than the OCTR, it is necessary to perform a large, randomized, controlled trial in which the utilities and resource use are measured prospectively.Keywords
This publication has 35 references indexed in Scilit:
- Endoscopic versus Open Carpal Tunnel Release: A Cost-Effectiveness AnalysisPlastic and Reconstructive Surgery, 1998
- The results of revision carpal tunnel release following previous open versus endoscopic surgeryThe Journal of Hand Surgery, 1998
- Endoscopic versus Open Carpal Tunnel Release: A Cost-Effectiveness AnalysisPlastic and Reconstructive Surgery, 1998
- Early Results of Conventional Versus Two-Portal Endoscopic Carpal Tunnel ReleaseJournal of Hand Surgery (European Volume), 1995
- Endoscopic carpal tunnel release: A prospective study of complications and surgical experienceThe Journal of Hand Surgery, 1995
- Endoscopic Carpal Tunnel DecompressionJournal of Hand Surgery (European Volume), 1994
- Endoscopic release of the carpal ligament: A new technique for carpal tunnel syndromeArthroscopy, 1989
- The history of carpal tunnnel syndromeJournal of Hand Surgery (European Volume), 1988
- Measurement of health state utilities for economic appraisalJournal of Health Economics, 1986
- The Carpal-tunnel SyndromeClinical Orthopaedics and Related Research, 1972