Comparison of PHITS, GEANT4, and HIBRAC simulations of depth-dependent yields of β+-emitting nuclei during therapeutic particle irradiation to measured data
Authors:
- Marlen PriegnitzMPMarlen Priegnitz
- Wolfgang EnghardtWEWolfgang Enghardt
- Fine FiedlerFFFine Fiedler
- 2 September 2013
- journal article
- research article
- Published by IOP Publishing in Physics in Medicine & Biology
- Vol. 58 (18) , 6355-6368
Abstract
For quality assurance in particle therapy, a non-invasive, in vivo range verification is highly desired. Particle therapy positron-emission-tomography (PT-PET) is the only clinically proven method up to now for this purpose. It makes use of the β(+)-activity produced during the irradiation by the nuclear fragmentation processes between the therapeutic beam and the irradiated tissue. Since a direct comparison of β(+)-activity and dose is not feasible, a simulation of the expected β(+)-activity distribution is required. For this reason it is essential to have a quantitatively reliable code for the simulation of the yields of the β(+)-emitting nuclei at every position of the beam path. In this paper results of the three-dimensional Monte-Carlo simulation codes PHITS, GEANT4, and the one-dimensional deterministic simulation code HIBRAC are compared to measurements of the yields of the most abundant β(+)-emitting nuclei for carbon, lithium, helium, and proton beams. In general, PHITS underestimates the yields of positron-emitters. With GEANT4 the overall most accurate results are obtained. HIBRAC and GEANT4 provide comparable results for carbon and proton beams. HIBRAC is considered as a good candidate for the implementation to clinical routine PT-PET.Keywords
This publication has 45 references indexed in Scilit:
- Interaction vertex imaging (IVI) for carbon ion therapy monitoring: a feasibility studyPhysics in Medicine & Biology, 2012
- Monte Carlo calculations of positron emitter yields in proton radiotherapyPhysics in Medicine & Biology, 2012
- Influence of nuclear de-excitation on observables relevant for space explorationAdvances In Space Research, 2011
- On the effectiveness of ion range determination from in-beam PET dataPhysics in Medicine & Biology, 2010
- In-beam PET measurement of7Li3+irradiation induced β+-activityPhysics in Medicine & Biology, 2008
- Patient Study of In Vivo Verification of Beam Delivery and Range, Using Positron Emission Tomography and Computed Tomography Imaging After Proton TherapyInternational Journal of Radiation Oncology - Biology - Physics (IJROBP), 2007
- The Feasibility of In-Beam PET for Therapeutic Beams of$^3$HeIEEE Transactions on Nuclear Science, 2006
- Relativistic nuclear collisions atGeV energies fromto Au+Au with the hadronic cascade modelPhysical Review C, 1999
- Factorization of fragment-production cross sections in relativistic heavy-ion collisionsPhysical Review C, 1983
- Monte Carlo calculation of high-energy heavy-ion interactionsPhysical Review C, 1980